Ask the Judge, 8/2/2007
Rules Tip of the Day: In the draw step, after the normal draw has occurred, each player will receive priority. You can use a spell or ability to cause your opponent to discard at this time.
Q: I have Rule of Law in play, and my opponent Suspends a card. On the turn that the Suspended card comes into play, can he still play another card? What if he has two Suspended cards that will come into play during the same turn?
A: No, your opponent cannot play another spell if he has already played a Suspended card this turn. When the card un-Suspends, that player must play it if possible. This is playing a spell, so Rule of Law will prevent him from playing any additional spells that turn. If there are two cards that would un-Suspend in the same turn, then their controller will be able to determine the order that their Suspend triggers go on the stack. The Suspend ability that goes on the stack last will resolve first and be the one that is played. The other spell will un-Suspend, but it cannot be played, so it will remain in the removed from game zone.
Q: Does Anvil of Bogardan negate the drawback of Pyromancer's Swath?
A: No, it does not. Pyromancer's Swath has a triggered ability that triggers at the beginning of your end of turn step. When this ability resolves, you discard your hand. It does not change your hand size in any way. Anvil of Bogarden does not prevent any effect from causing you to discard, it only prevents the rules from doing so. With both of these permanents in play, you will still discard your hand in the end of turn step of your turn.
Q: When I cast Sculpting Steel with an Epochrasite in play, and choose to copy it, will the new copy of Epochrasite have 3 +1/+1 counters on it? If the copy is destroyed, will it be Suspended like a real Epochrasite?
A: You did play this Sculpting Steel / Epochrasite spell from your hand, so it will not get the +1/+1 counters. However, when Sculpting Steel / Epochrasite is destroyed, it will be be removed from the game, gain Suspend, and get three time counters. In the removed from game zone and when it goes back on the stack, it will be a Sculpting Steel. This means that you can choose to copy some other artifact when the Sculpting Steel resolves again. If you choose to copy the Epochrasite again, then it will get the +1/+1 counters this time, since you did not play it from your hand.
Q: What's the ruling on Body Double and Phage the Untouchable? I heard that you won't lose the game if you reanimate Phage this way. Is this true?
A: Yes, that is correct, so long as you played the Body Double spell from your hand. Body Double will enter play as a Phage, but its ability will not trigger. This is because you played this spell form your hand, it does not matter that it was not a Phage spell. With Body Double you are not reanimating Phage; you are playing a spell that comes into play as a copy of Phage.
Q: I attack with Spectral Force and my opponent blocks it with a Darkheart Sliver. After putting damage on the stack, assigning two damage to the Sliver and six to my opponent, my opponent sacrifices his Sliver to gain three life. Does my opponent take six or eight damage?
A: Combat damage is dealt as it is assigned, if able. It does not matter that the Sliver that was in play and assigned two points of damage is not in play when combat damage resolves, this does not change the assignment. This means that the defending player will receive six points of damage and that the two assigned to the Darkheart Sliver will not be dealt at all, as there is nothing to deal this damage to.
Q: My opponent declares his Tombstalker as an attacker. I have a Sacred Mesa in play. When he declares the attacker, I don't do anything. Then I declare blockers, and put a Pegasus in play blocking the Tombstalker, but he says that he will Sudden Death my Pegasus as soon as it comes into play, so I make another token again blocking the Demon. My opponent says I can't block anymore, because I already declared blockers. Is he correct?
A: Neither of you is playing in a technically correct manner. In order for a creature to block, it must be in play when the declaration of blockers step begins. This means that you need to activate the ability of your Sacred Mesa in the declaration of attackers step (you will have a chance to take actions in this step after he declares who is attacking) in order to have a Pegasus token to block with. You only advance to the next step or phase until both players pass priority on an empty stack without doing anything. So after the Sacred Mesa ability resolves, your opponent can play Sudden Death and kill the Pegasus token that just came into play. Keep in mind that this is still before blockers have been declared. Because this is the case, you can then activate Sacred Mesa's ability again to make a new token creature to block with. Then, when both of you do pass into the declaration of blockers step, this newly created token can block.
Q: I was playing an Emperor Format game using the deploy creatures option, with general having range one and emperors range two. I was an emperor and cast Ray of Command during my turn to take control of an opposing general's creature. Then I used the deploy creatures rule to give control of this creature to the general on my left. What happens at the end of the turn? Does my general keep the creature? Or does it go back to my opponent?
A: Your general will keep control of this creature. Control Effect are often compared to layers of paint. In this example, the effect from the Deploy ability will be the topmost layer and the Ray of Command layer will be just underneath it. This means that while both effect are being applied, your teammate will control this creature. At the end of the current turn, the control effect created by Ray of Command will end, but the change in control effect from the Deploy ability will not. The fact that a control effect 'underneath' the Deploy effect goes away does not mean that the deploy creature effect will end. Your teammate will maintain control of this creature until the creature leaves play or some other control effect is applied to the creature.





The Time Spiral Block Constructed metagame is constantly evolving. Early in the season, it seemed that White/Green Tarmogoyf would...
Today's Deep Analysis sees Richard "U/B Control" Feldman continues in his rich vein of form as he tackles one of the more intriguing matchups in Time Spiral...
I normally keep a box of bad rares... er.... "low value" rares by my computer. I already took them out of the box so I could use it for something else. Now I...
Hello everybody, and welcome to another Issues article. Today sees Evan rant long and hard about the quietness of August, the shoddiness of the Magic Online Version 3 Beta, the ridiculousness of the cult of Magic celebrity, and...
Sean is taking a brief vacation from writing Magical Hack. We've got a few interesting submissions lined up for the next few weeks: a few old faces you'll be...
It's the weekend, so that means one thing: Flores Friday. Today's offering from Mike showcases a plethora of practical information on the relevant formats, from the front lines. He shares his U.S. Grinders decklist, and Osyp's...
Tiago turns his back on Constructed for this week's Levelling Up... instead, taking advantage of the Nix Tix events on Magic Online, the Portuguese maestro powers through sixteen 8-4 TPF Drafts, and shares his thoughs on the color...
I really like Aethermage's Touch. It won me several game 1s that I couldn't have possibly won otherwise. That said, a lot of people don't like it, and I don't...
Last weekend, Craig "The Professor" Jones pulled himself out of his Magical doldrums to win the Great British National Championship....
This is the story of my personal performance at last weekend's UK National Championship. In particular, it looks at the highs, and lows, of my Limited game, and...
Everyone does a “Lessons From...” piece on a tournament, especially when they don’t do all that well, and the tendency is for these to be quite...
I’ve been playing Magic for nearly 14 years now, and I’ve always dreamed of going to Nationals. Since I haven’t ever qualified, I could really...
Stephen Menendian, the Voice of Vintage, continues his championing of GroAtog as the premier deck in Vintage. However, there's...
With both U.S. and UK Nationals now in the books, the Standard metagame is beginning to take shape. One of the major players in this evolving meta is Gabe Walls...
Kevin presents the deck he believes is the best choice for the upcoming Legacy championships. He's been tuning a combo-control deck for over five months, and he's finally ready to share the
Today's From Right Field sees Chris return to familiar ground: he updates his Staple Rare list to include both Coldsnap and Tenth Edition. As both sets have a... 










