Ask the Judge, 11/26/2007
Rules Tip of the Day: The Graft ability does not target anything. You can move a +1/+1 counter onto a creature that cannot be targeted with the Graft triggered ability.
Q: When I play a Command spell from Lorwyn, do the two effects resolve simultaneously, or is there a moment's delay between the two? For example: can a Cryptic Command counter a Hellbent Demonfire on its own, by bouncing a permanent back to the Demonfire's controller's hand, then countering the spell? Or would it fail, as the abilities resolve at the same time?
A: What you want to do does not work, but not because these two effect are applied at the same time. When you resolve a Lorwyn Command, you apply the two chosen modes in the order that they are written on the card. Because the 'counter a spell' mode on Cryptic Command comes first, you will attempt to apply that first in any situation. Because you attempt to counter the targeted Demonfire before the targeted permanent is returned to its owner's hand, it will not counter the spell in this example.
Q: My opponent attacks with two creatures. I declare two blockers. He casts Devouring Light on one of my creatures. In response, I cast Wild Richochet on his Devouring Light. He argues that because Devouring Light targets a blocker, his attockers aren't legal targets for the spell or its copy. But Devouring Light says "attacking or blocking creature." Can I kill off his team here?
A: Devouring Light is not a modal spell; whether a creature is attacking or blocking does not matter, as long as it is one or the other. An individual Devouring Light or a copy of one can target an attacking or blocking creature. If the target is changed, it can be changed to any creature in combat.
Q: Does Pithing Needle stop Militia's Pride from making tokens?
A: No. Militia's Pride has a triggered ability, not an activated ability. It does not matter that there is a mana payment when this triggered ability resolves; it is still not affected by Pithing Needle's ability.
Q: During my opponent's upkeep, I play Mistbind Clique, Championing a Glen Elendra Pranksters. Can I use the triggered ability from Glen Elendra Pranksters to return the Mistbind Clique to my hand?
A: No, that ability triggers when you play a spell, not when a spell resolves. It will trigger and go on the stack when you play the Mistbind Clique spell; it will go on the stack on top of the Clique spell. When it does, you need to choose a target for the ability. The Clique is not in play yet, so it cannot be targeted.
Q: If I cast Briarhorn on my opponent's end of turn and target itself with its ability, will it be a 6/6 creature that can attack on my turn?
A: No. The effect from Briarhorn's comes-into-play ability lasts until the end of a turn, which occurs in the cleanup step, after the end of turn step. Effect like this cannot carry over into another turn.
Q: I was wanting to know what happens when you have Azorius First-Wing and Concerted Effort in play, does it create a paradox?
A: No. Concerted Effort's ability does not target anything. A creature in play with protection from enchantments can still be affected by Concerted Effort's effect. In fact, because you control an Azorius First-Wing, all creature you control will gain protection from enchantments.
Q: How exactly does Crovax, Ascendant Hero interact with Lightning Angel? I've been told the modifiers simply cancel each other out. Is this the case?
A: No. Lightning Angel is a white creature. It does not matter that is is also blue and red, this does not make it non-white. A permanent cannot be both white and non-white. Because of this, a Lightning Angel will be a 4/5 creature with Crovax, Ascendent Hero in play.
Q: Will Spirit Link on a creature that kills itself as a result of doing damage (such as Hammerfist Giant) grant life to its controller?
A: Yes, as the Spirit Link will be in play when damage is actually dealt. It does not matter that the Spirit Link will soon leave play after state-based effects are checked. (Technically, when they are checked a second time. The first time they are checked the Giant will leave play, and then immediately after they are checked again.)
Q: Can I pay for an Arcbound Wanderer with one mana of each color and one mana from a Snow permanent to give it six +1/+1 tokens?
A: No, Snow is not a color. The Sunburst ability only cares about the colors of mana that were spent to play the spell. What mana comes from a Snow permanent does not matter at all.
Q: Can I attack with my Chimeric Idol and Mishra's Factory at the same time?
A: Not normally. In order to attack with either of these permanents, they must be creatures when attacking creatures are declared. For that to happen, the Mishra's Factory would be tapped and therefore unable to be chosen as an attacking creature. [Though if you had a way to give creatures haste, you could play and animate the Factory after you activated the Idol. -Seamus]





Seven cards are better than six. This much we know. But how often can we be sure that the hand we’re keeping is stronger than a prospective six? Dan Paskins...
Grand Prix: Daytona Beach taught the world a thing or two about the nuances of Lorwyn Limited. Tribal concerns, color shenanigans, and card evaluation were all...
Welcome back to the series on Faeries. This should be the last or next to last article I need to write on the subject, since I’ll basically have covered the...
This week, Rich Hagon invites you to put your brain into high gear, let the scales drop from your eyes, and discover how you can beat the online Pros at their own Drafting game. If you can't work out why they pick what they pick,...
Deckbuilding is difficult. Sure, it’s relatively easy to come up with a semi-competitive deck, one that could do some rocking in an 8-man queue of an FNM…...
Lorwyn drafting, both online and in real life, are now in full swing. We’ve had many a primer article here on StarCityGames.com, including a number of...
That's right, folks: The "Drafting With..." series is back! Taking up where both Rich Hoaen and Kenji Tsumura left off, we have Level 6 Mage Tiago Chan. As before, Tiago takes us through a triple Lorwyn draft from pick 1 to pick...
Can’t make this stuff up, folks. Get a message from Dan Ackroyd - okay, Danny Ackroyd-Isales, but story value, people, story value - asking about Rock and...
I’m fond of Lorwyn. I think it’s a fine set. However, there is only so much I want to write on it before I get bored. Three consecutive weeks of pouring over...
Hello everybody, and welcome to another edition of the Magic Show. This week's show is just too scatterbrained to stay on one topic. I haven't ranted about anything in weeks, and now it's time to dish. On this week's episode we go...
Last week, we began looking at the most recent format of relevance to tournament play – Lorwyn Sealed Deck. It only makes sense to follow up on that subject...
A Standard Pro Tour looms in the New Year, and who wouldn’t want a trip to Hollywood? In order to qualify, one must triumph at an Extended PTQ. The season...
Tiago Chan, without a clear goal to hit in the Pro Player’s Club, was a little reluctant to attend Grand Prix: Daytona Beach. However, a Magical holiday is...
I have tried to follow hunches and ideas in decks even when they are ludicrous or go against the conventional wisdom. The most frequent result is utter junk; it turns out that conventional wisdom can be pretty wise. Sometimes I...
For Thanksgiving, The Ferrett LARPed a classic computer game and drove all the way across the East Coast with a trunk full of food... Oh yeah, and played some... 









