Ask the Judge 12/20/2007
Rules Tip of the Day: Many older cards were printed with abilities that required you to make a payment or perform an action 'during your upkeep.' Most of these have received errata so that they are triggered abilities that trigger at the beginning of your upkeep. Check the Oracle to be sure what the current official text is.
Q: I play Profane Command and say I'll have a target player lose X life, and target his creature to get -X/-X. He plays Rebuff the Wicked to counter the -X/-X effect on his creature. Will my Profane Command be countered entirely, including the "lose X life" effect of the command?
A: Yes. Rebuff the Wicked counters any spell that targets a permanent controlled by the controller of Rebuff the Wicked. It does not just negate the parts of a spell that target this permanent. This means that this entire Profane Command will be countered and your opponent will not lose any life.
Q: If I have a Words of Wind in play, can I play Mulldrifter via Evoke, choose to draw one card and pay one to bounce the Mulldrifter, back to my hand?
A: Yes, although technically speaking you will return the Mulldrifter to your hand when you attempt to draw the first card, and then you will draw the second card. This is because in order for this combo to work, you need to play Mulldrifter via Evoke, and put the sacrifice trigger on the stack first followed by the 'draw two cards' trigger. Additionally, any time before either of the triggered abilities resolves, you need to activate the ability of your Words of Wind. Then when the top trigger resolves, you will return the Mulldrifter to your hand and then draw a card. Your opponent will return a permanent he or she controls to its owner's hand, too.
Q: I have in play four random Goblins and a Boggart Shenanigans. My opponent has Story Circle in play and has chosen red. On his turn, he plays Wrath of God. How many times would he have to play Story Circle's ability to prevent all of the damage to him from Boggart Shenanigans?
A: He will have to activate the Story Circle four times. In this situation, Boggart Shenanigans' ability will trigger four times, once for each Goblin that goes to the graveyard. Each one of these triggered abilities will end up dealing one point of damage to your opponent. An individual prevention effect from a Story Circle will only prevent the damage from the chosen source the next time that it deals damage. To prevent all of this damage, he will need to create four different prevention shields.
Q: Since Thoughtweft Trio has first strike and can block any number of creatures, if it blocked ten creatures with lower defense than its attack could it kill them all without dying?
A: Barring any other effects, it would be impossible for it to block 10 guys with a toughness lower than the Trio's power, as the Trio has a power of five. An attacking creature deals damage equal to its power divided amongst the creatures that are blocking it, not damage equal to its power to each creature blocking it.
Q: If I use Bringer of the White Dawn's ability to bring an artifact land back into play, does that count towards my one land per turn limit?
A: No. You are not playing this land; you are putting it into play. You can only play one land during your turn, but there is no limit to the number of lands that you can put into play, provided that various effects allow you to do so.
Q: My friend and I were playing with Highlander decks and my friend had all five basic lands in play and another set of five Snow basic lands. He also had Collective Restraint in play. He said that, since he had both the normal and Snowlands, I would have to pay ten mana for each attacking creature. Is this right?
A: No. Collective Restraint count the number of basic land types that you control. Snow is a supertype. If your opponent controlled only Islands and Snow-Covered Islands, you would only have to pay one mana. In this example, you would only have to pay five mana for each attacking creature.





For the final article in Zvi’s “My Worlds” Tournament Report, Zvi walks us through each of his Legacy matches in turn, sharing the highs and the lows with...
Extended is coming, and all eyes turn to the older cards. In today’s Deep Analysis, Richard debates the nature of power in the format, and defines what he...
That’s right folks, it’s the end of another year... and that means it’s time for awards! Today, we have Kyle Sanchez handing out his own personal plaudits and brickbats, for those professional mages that have either excelled...
Tiago Chan, Portugal's Level 6 Magic dynamo, takes us by the hand and leads us through the choppy waters of a triple-Lorwyn draft on Magic Online. He shares each and every pick, from one to forty-five, and supplies expert...
I think that the best Magic writers are good at doing two things well. Firstly, you have to be inventive, and create your own material. In order to be a good...
Hello everybody and welcome to another edition of the Magic Show. This week I wrap up my Worlds experience by talking to players about Lorwyn draft, favorite...
With the Extended PTQ season right around the corner, the time is nigh to look into figuring out what you want to do in the format and how it plays out. First appearances can be deceiving, after all, and if you start with "just"...
Today’s Flores Friday follows hot on the heels of Michaelj Monday’s "The Breakdown of Theory" article. Mike fleshes out his fresh and exciting Phases of Magic concept, looking back at various dominant strategies in an attempt...
With Day 2 of Worlds concentrating on the Legacy format, it was a chance for the pro community to flex their Eternal muscles. While Tiago Chan was out of...
"[Expletive]! I got another crappy Hideaway land!"
I’ve talked a lot over the last couple of weeks about focus. About how I think I’ve been able to keep my mind in the right place, and as a consequence how my results have been improving. But there haven’t been many...
In this fascinating article, Vintage World Champion Stephen Menendian examines a fundamental flaw in human intelligence: the inability to make optimal strategic...
Extended PTQ season is right around the corner, and today’s Peebles Primers takes a look at some of the decks that could be strong going in. Using a Zoo deck as a litmus test, Benjamin Peebles-Mundy puts Zac Hill’s Rock and...
I went. I participated. I lost a total of two matches in five days. That would have been amazing, if I had been a competitor. I was a judge. Let me tell you about that. I’ll even explain how I became Lithuanian for an hour, and...
Examining one’s own thought processes during a slump is a tricky business. As I wrote in 










