Ask the Judge 1/8/2008
Rules Tip of the Day: When a land has its type changed into a basic land type, it will lose all of its text and gain the text of the appropriate mana ability. It will retain any supertypes it has, like Legendary, Basic, or Snow.
Q: If I use Makeshift Mannequin to bring Akroma, Angel of Wrath back to play, would it have a mannequin counter on it, even though Akroma has protection from black when in play?
A: Yes. When Makeshift Mannequin revolves, it puts the targeted creature into play with a mannequin counter on it. This is all part of the effect of returning it to play. A protection ability will not affect this in any way.
Q: My opponent has an Oona Prowler in play and I want to reduce its power by using its discard ability to give it -2/0. I am holding a Guerrilla Tactics in hand. If I discard Guerrilla Tactics, will it deal four` damage to a player or creature?
A: No. Guerilla Tactic's ability only triggers when you discard it due to an effect controlled by an opponent. When you discard a card to lower Oona's Prowler's power, you are discarding to pay a cost, and you are the controller of this ability.
Q: Can I use Chisei, Heart of the Ocean for removing counters from Suspended cards?
A: No. Chisei's upkeep triggered ability only allows you to remove counters from permanents you control. Objects can only be permanents when in play. Suspended cards are removed from the game, and are therefore not permanents. This is true even if it is a card that will enter play as a permanent when it resolves.
Q: If I remove a +1/+1 counter from Arcbound Reclaimer with Power Conduit, would it activate the Reclaimer's ability?
A: No. In order to activate Arcbound Recalimer's ability, you specifically need to remove a counter to pay the activation cost of that ability. Removing a counter from it in any other way will not cause this ability to activate.
Q: I have Eryao, Soratami Ascendant in play, and three spells have been played this turn. My opponent plays the forth spell—a Shock—targeting me, and then another Shock, targeting Erayo, as the fifth spell. Will Erayo die or flip?
A: Provided that your opponent plays the second Shock as soon as he can without passing priority, then Erayo will end up receiving lethal damage and go to the graveyard. When your opponent plays the fourth spell (the first Shock), Erayo's ability will trigger. This trigger will go on the stack on top of this Shock. At this point, your opponent will still have priority, and he can play the additional Shock now. Assuming nothing else is played, then this topmost Shock will resolve and deal lethal damage to Erayo before it flips. (In tournament play it is assumed that you pass priority after playing a spell unless you specifically state you are not passing. On MTGO, you need to hold control to keep priority after playing a spell.)
Q: I sacrifice False Prophet when I play Recurring Nightmare's ability; will the creature I return to play be removed from the game?
A: No. You sacrifice a creature when you play Recurring Nightmare's ability. Any abilities that trigger on this action will go on the stack on top of Recurring Nightmare's ability and will resolve before Recurring Nightmare does. You do not return the targeted creature card from your graveyard to play until this ability resolves, so that creature will not be in play yet.
Q: I have a Panoptic Mirror with Pulse of the Tangle imprinted on it. During my next upkeep I copy the Pulse and play it for no mana. My oppenent has more creatures than I do. Do I end up with the token equivalent of the card in my hand? If not, why not?
A: The copy of Pulse of the Tangle is returned to your hand. However, as it is not an actual card, it will cease to exist.
Q: If I have Cabal Coffers, ten Swamps, and Infernal Darkness in play, will the Cabal Coffers only produce one mana?
A: Yes. Cabal Coffers' mana ability will only be able to generate one black mana because of the effect from Infernal Darkness. As it costs two mana to activate this ability, you will end up losing mana.
Q: If I cast Summoner's Egg and Donate it to my opponent, and the Egg goes to the graveyard and puts the Imprinted creature into play, will Brand give me control of the creature?
A: Yes, you are still the owner of this card. It does not matter that your opponent is the one who played the spell and had the permanent come into play under his control.





Adrian is in a disagreeable mood. Today’s Sullivan Library looks back at some of things, people, and ideas that have ground his gears in 2007. He disagrees...
As promised last week, today’s Limited Lessons opens the door on an intriguing power-packed Lorwyn draft archetype, as Nick walks us through an 8-4 draft that...
Tiago Chan, Portugal's Magic dynamo, takes us by the hand and leads us through the choppy waters of a triple-Lorwyn draft on Magic Online. He shares each and every pick, from one to forty-five, and supplies expert commentary on...
In the wake of Worlds, we have several new and revitalized decks to pore over. Doug takes a look at Welder Survival, long a deck sitting just beyond the horizon...
When last I wrote this column, I was undecided what deck to play for the Pro Tour: Hollywood Qualifier I was attending down at the Star City Game Center. I had the “Doran Goodstuff” deck ready to roll; it was already pulled...
As everyone knows, I don’t play a lot of Magic Online. Whenever I do, I have experiences like the one yesterday that make me loathe the anonymity of the Internet and the readiness with which people take advantage of
Vintage, it seems, has turned from the combo table, opting instead to feast on the attack step. Stephen Menendian, Vintage World Champion, takes his GAT deck into the Workshop Aggro fray, with mixed results. As usual, the detail...
The PTQ results are in, and it seems the Extended metagame is as diverse as we’d hoped… and as confusing as we’d feared. Nevertheless, though the fog we...
Uri Peleg, World Champion 2007, rounds out his entertaining tournament report in style! He brings us five rounds of top-drawer Legacy action, followed by a...
Extended is a complicated format, with intricately constructed decks and even more complex manabases supporting them. Tom shows you how to use Onslaught’s...
He made the final of Worlds 2007… so what’s next? In today’s Innovations, Patrick Chapin takes his potent Next Level Blue Extended deck into the PTQ field,...
Today will be a grab bag of sorts as lately I’ve gotten a lot of playing time in on Magic Online while waiting for real results to come in. Of course, now that...
Season 2008 is upon us, so now's the time to bid farewell to 2007 with an Award ceremony featuring the contenders and winners of such need-to-know categories as...
For his three hundredth article for StarCityGames.com, The Ferrett has done something special - he's ventured onto Evan Erwin's turf and gone to YouTube! Watch... 









