Ask the Judge 1/9/2008
Rules Tip of the Day: Only spells and abilities that use the word target actually target other objects. The exception to this is that Aura and some keyword abilities do target, even though they do not explicitly say so in their rules text. (They may refer to targeting in the reminder text.)
Q: Can you Spell Snare an Evoked Shriekmaw?
A: No. The converted mana cost of a Shreikmaw spell is five; it does not matter if it was played via its Evoke cost.
Q: I attack with Galepowder Mage and choose to remove from play Mangara of Corondor. Can I tap Mangara and use his ability, removing a permanent from play and then have him back at the end of my turn, as Galepowder Mage resolves?
A: No, that does not work, because Galepowder Mage's ability is a triggered ability, so you do not have that much control over when that ability goes on the stack. If you attack with Galepowder Mage, its ability will trigger and go on the stack. You can choose to target Mangara at this time. However, if you respond to this triggered ability by activating Mangara's ability, then Mangara's ability will resolve first. This will cause Mangara to be removed from the game permanently before Galepowder Mage's ability can temporarily remove it from the game.
Q: Can Oblivion Ring work on a Suspended card?
A: No, the Suspended card is not a permanent in play. Suspended cards are cards in the removed from game zone.
Q: If I enchant my opponent's Ohran Viper with Pariah, then he attacks with the Viper alone for one point of damage, will Pariah's replacement effect kill the Viper?
A: Yes. The damage from this Ohran Viper will be redirected from you to itself. This will cause the Viper's first ability to trigger. Then later, in the end of combat step, the Viper will be destroyed. (Technically, the Pariah's replacement effect does not destroy the Viper, it just sets it up so that the delayed triggered ability made by the Viper's own ability destroys it.)
Q: I have two Doubling Seasons in play and a Soul Foundry with an Arcbound Crusher inprinted on it. When I activate the Soul Foundry, I get four Arcbound Crushers. Do they all come into play simultaneously? And how many +1/+1 counters will each end up with?
A: These four Arcbound Crushers come into play with four +1/+1 counters on them. As they all come into play at the same time, their abilities will trigger once for each other. (So a total of 12 triggered abilities will go on the stack, three for each Crusher.) Each time one of these abilities resolves, the appropriate Arcbound Crusher will receive four +1/+1. When all of this has resolved, each Crusher will have 16 +1/+1 counter on it.
Q: I have Intruder Alarm and Meeskstone in play. When I play a creature spell, will my opponent's creatures with power three or more untap (because of Intruder Alarm's ability)?
A: Yes. Meekstone only prevent creatures from untapping as normal during their controller's untap step. It does not prevent anything from untapping at any other time.
Q: Serrated Biskelion, with one -1/-1 counter on it, is enchanted with Sadistic Glee. If the Serrated Biskelion uses its ability to kill another creature, are the -1/-1 and the +1/+1 counters canceled out, due to rule 420.5n, saving the Serrated Biskelion?
A: They would if they were both on the Serrated Biskelion at the same time, but that won't happen in this example. When the Biskelion's ability resolves, the targeted creature and the Biskelion will both receive a -1/-1 counter. Then state-based effects will be checked and both the Biskelion and the targeted creature will go to the graveyard, as they have a toughness of zero. This will cause the ability of Sadistic Glee to trigger; when this ability resolves, the Biskelion (and the Sadistic Glee) will be in the graveyard.
Q: Do Snow-Covered Mountains count for Spitting Earth?
A: Yes, when Spitting Earth resolves, it will deal damage to the targeted creature equal to the number of lands you control with the type Mountain. Lands you control that have this type but do not have the actually name of Mountain are counted.
Q: Is Thran Golem considered "enchanted" and does it receive it's +2/+2 bonus if the enchantment Serra's Blessing is in play and affecting it?
A: No. In order to be enchanted, the Golem must have an Aura attached to it.





The Extended PTQ season is beginning. A lot of people will be writing about the techie new decks, and what won which PTQ. I’ll chip in with a couple of other...
With the Week 1 Extended PTQ results now in Richard Feldman looks at the trends and patterns from the successful decklists across the world. It’s clear that...
Extended is a rich tapestry of options, and Kyle is almost driven blind by the sweetmeats on display. Today’s Down And Dirty sees Mr Sanchez swinging with the...
Tiago Chan, Portugal's Magic dynamo, takes us by the hand and leads us through the choppy waters of a triple-Lorwyn draft on Magic Online. He shares each and every pick, from one to forty-five, and supplies expert commentary on...
Hello folks, and welcome back to the column charged with the exploration of all things casual. I’m your continuing host, Abe Sargent. Today, I have a...
Hello everybody, and welcome to another edition of the Magic Show. This past week I was fortunate enough to spend a weekend in Roanoke, Virginia for the PTQ and...
Often, I pride myself on my ability to figure out what is important to a Constructed format, and build around that in a complicated dance of design and re-design. I seek to find a deck that I am comfortable with that I believe...
Adrian is in a disagreeable mood. Today’s Sullivan Library looks back at some of things, people, and ideas that have ground his gears in 2007. He disagrees...
As promised last week, today’s Limited Lessons opens the door on an intriguing power-packed Lorwyn draft archetype, as Nick walks us through an 8-4 draft that...
In the wake of Worlds, we have several new and revitalized decks to pore over. Doug takes a look at Welder Survival, long a deck sitting just beyond the horizon...
When last I wrote this column, I was undecided what deck to play for the Pro Tour: Hollywood Qualifier I was attending down at the Star City Game Center. I had the “Doran Goodstuff” deck ready to roll; it was already pulled...
As everyone knows, I don’t play a lot of Magic Online. Whenever I do, I have experiences like the one yesterday that make me loathe the anonymity of the Internet and the readiness with which people take advantage of
Vintage, it seems, has turned from the combo table, opting instead to feast on the attack step. Stephen Menendian, Vintage World Champion, takes his GAT deck into the Workshop Aggro fray, with mixed results. As usual, the detail...
The PTQ results are in, and it seems the Extended metagame is as diverse as we’d hoped… and as confusing as we’d feared. Nevertheless, though the fog we... 









