Ask the Judge, 1/22/2008
Rules Tip of the Day: The words 'each' and 'all' do not denote or imply targeting.
Q: I have a Preeminent Captain in play. If I attack, could I then put a Bushi Tenderfoot into play, but flipped so that he's actually Kenzo the Hardhearted?
A: No. Unless specified, when you put a card into play, it is put into play as it normally enter play. A Bushi Tenderfoot can be put into play when this ability resolves, but only as the unflipped Bushi Tendrefoot.
Q: If I have both Guile and Dovescape in play, and I play a spell, would I be able to play it with Guile's ability, counter it with Dovescape, and get infinite Birds?
A: Yes, that does work. When Dovescape's ability resolves, Guile will cause you to remove this noncreature spell from the game. You will still get Bird tokens equal to the converted mana cost of this spell. Guile will allow you to replay this spell for free. When you do, Dovescape's ability will trigger again. You can repeat this process over and over as many times as you want. You will have to stop with a specific number; infinite is not a number in Magic.
Q: My opponent plays Meddling Mage, naming Tooth and Nail. I then play Lignify targeting the Meddling Mage. Am I now allowed to play Tooth and Nail?
A: Yes. Meddling Mage's ability that prevents you from playing the chosen card will be removed by Lignify.
Q: Does Gaddock Teeg stop me from playing Sprout Swarm with buyback? The casting cost is 1G but the buyback cost is three, for a total of five mana.
A: No. The converted mana cost of Sprout Swarm, even when the buyback cost is paid, is two. The converted mana cost of a spell is the total amount of mana in the upper right corner of the card. Effects that raise or lower the cost to play this spell or optional costs added to the spell are not part of the converted mana cost.
Q: How do Guile and Pact of Negation interact? Guile has a replacement effect when you cast a counterspell; does this override the requirement to pay 3UU the next turn or lose?
A: It does not matter that Guile's ability replaces a portion of what happens when Pact of Negation resolves. When Pact of Negation resolves, the targeted spell is removed from the game and you can play it, but Pact of Negation will also still create a delayed triggered ability that will cause you to lose in your next upkeep unless you pay 3UU. Similarly, you would draw a card with Dismiss and you would untap up to four lands if Rewind were the counterspell in this example.
Q: Can Nomad Mythmaker fetch me an Animate Dead from my graveyard?
A: No. In order to attach the targeted Aura to a creature card in play it must have the ability 'Enchant creature.' This is because you cannot attach an Aura to an object that it cannot be legally attached to. The card Animate Dead has the ability 'Enchant creature card in a graveyard.' It can be targeted by Mythmaker's ability, but nothing will happen when this ability resolves.
Q: I have a Protean Hulk hidden under a Mosswort Bridge. I play a Phyrexian Dreadnought, and activate the Bridge and play the Hulk with the sacrifice ability on the stack. I sacrifice Dreadnought and Hulk to Dreadnought's comes-into-play trigger, leaving Hulk as the top card in the graveyard, and fetch Dracoplasm, another Dreadnought, and Volrath's Shapeshifter (now a copy of Protean Hulk). Can I now sacrifice the new Dreadnought and Shapeshifter to Dracoplasm?
A: No. All of the creatures that are put into play when Protean Hulk's ability resolves enter play at the same time. And Dracoplasm's ability is no longer a triggered ability; it is a static ability that generates a replacement effect that is applied as Dracoplasm enters play. You sacrifice creatures to Dracoplasm's ability as it comes into play. This means that you must sacrifice creatures that were in play before Dracoplasm entered play.
Q: I have a Ghostly Prison in play, and my friend plays a Ward Sliver, choosing white. Does that mean that now he can attack me without paying two mana?
A: No. Ghostly Prison does not deal damage, it is not an Aura enchantment or equipment, it has nothing to do with creature combat damage, and it does not target. Because of this, protection from white will not prevent a player from having to pay the cost when attacking.
Q: I have four Forbidden Orchards in play. I tap them for four red mana and play Aether Flash. I have an Avatar of Might in my hand and no creatures in play. Can I play the Avatar for two mana, or does the Aether Flash come into play first and blow up the tokens?
A: There's no way to destroy these tokens with your Aether Flash. If you tap these lands for mana before you play Aether Flash, then you will have to wait for the triggered abilities that put these token creatures into play to resolve before you can play the Aether Flash. If you tap these lands for mana during the announcement of Aether Flash, then these triggers will go on the stack on top of the Aether Flash spell and resolve first. In either situation, these tokens will enter play before your Aether Flash. This means that after the Aether Flash spell resolves, you can play the Avatar of Might for just GG.





At first glance, it’s easy to spot the chase cards in Morningtide. There’s Mutavault, for example. And Murmuring Bosk. Another card that is warranting a lot...
The Morningtide Prerelease has come and gone… I hope you all had fun! In today’s Limited Lessons, Nick shares his initial thoughts on the newest set....
Tiago Chan, Portugal's Magic dynamo, takes us by the hand and leads us through the choppy waters of a triple-Lorwyn draft on Magic Online. He shares each and every pick, from one to forty-five, and supplies expert commentary on...
Zac is having a week off this week. In his place, we have the inestimable Cedric Phillips! In his own words...
Run for the hills, ye little children. Oh, grab your skirts and start for the border, little ankles flying a-everywhich way, some jackass has given me a table on...
When a new set comes out, we all look for cards that’ll make a splash in our favorite format. Vintage players usually find this task a short one – Magic’s...
Although he missed the Morningtide Prerelease through travel commitments, Benjamin Peebles-Mundy was determined to get his first taste of the Lor-Lor-Mor Draft...
Ever since Legions, I have, without fail, provided you a set review of each new set from a Five Color perspective. This time,...
At 2007 Worlds, Threshold claimed the title of "Best Deck in Legacy," making the Threshold mirror match the most important and prevalent matchup for the deck. Kevin Binswanger has a guide to building, playing, and sideboarding for...
Morningtide is finally here (functionally), so it’s time to break out the hot new Constructed tech! Today’s Innovations does just that: Patrick Chapin brings...
Going into an Extended PTQ with a true plan in mind is one of the more daunting tasks I’ve seen in recent memory, thanks to the wide range of strategies and...
The Pre-Release is about cards. The Pre-Release is about players. But it's about a lot more besides, and Rich Hagon brings you some unique perspectives on the...
It’s amusing the expressions of horror I get from the surprising number of Magic players who view cellophane-wrapped booster box of product as several evenings... 










