Ask the Judge, 4/21/2008
Rules Tip of the Day: You can float mana from step to step within a phase. This means you can put mana in your mana pool in the upkeep step and use it in the draw step, or put it in your pool during the declaration of attacker step and later spend it in the combat damage step. But once a phase ends, any mana left in your pool will cause mana burn.
Q: If I have Swans of Byrn Argoll in play along, with Seismic Assualt. I discard Dakmor Salvage and dredge it back with the first draw. Can I respond to the trigger of the second draw by repeating the process with the end result of stacking 20 draws and then drawing all 20 cards at once?
A: No. First of all, Swans of Byrn Argoll's ability is not a triggered ability that uses the stack. Its ability is a static ability that generates a prevention effect. This prevention effect has an added effect that will cause the controller of the source of the prevented damage to draw cards. When damage would be dealt to the Swans, instead the controller of the damage will draw that many cards. While these cards are drawn one at a time, no one will receive priority in between each of the draws.
Q: If I have a Diviner's Wand equipped to a creature, and I draw a card and then equip the Wand to a different creature, will the first creature still get +1/+1 and have flying?
A: Yes. Diviner's Wand gives the equipped creature a triggered ability. This triggered ability affects the creature that was equipped by the Wand when the ability triggered, and will continue to do so until the end of turn. Moving the Wand to another creature will not remove the effect from the initial creature.
Q: I have Null Profusion and Colfenor's Plans in play. Will I draw a card when I play a card that was removed form the game by the Plans?
A: Yes. That ability of Null Profusion will trigger whenever you play a card, regardless of what zone you play the card from.
Q: I have Cream of the Crop in play, and I play a Riftwing Cloudskate. I target a Mulldrifter with the Cloudskate's ability and Cream of the Crop's ability goes on the stack. Before this ability resolves, my opponent Nameless Inversions my Skate; do I still get the effect of Cream of the Crop?
A: Yes; in fact, you'll be able to look at even more cards on top of your library than you would before. Cream of the Crop's ability uses the power of the creature that just came into play when its ability resolves, or the last-known information about this creature when it was in play. When this Cloudskate was last in play, it was a 5/-1 creature. The fact that its toughness was below zero is what caused it to go to the graveyard, but that does not matter for Cream of the Crop's ability. Because its power was five at that point, you'll be able to look at the top five cards of your library, choose one to keep on top and put the rest on the bottom of your library.
Q: If I have played Enduring Ideal, can I get more than one Tidal Influence into play? I think I can, because Enduring Ideal does not have me "play" the enchantment; I just put it into play.
A: You are correct. When you resolve Enduring Ideal or a copy of Enduring Ideal, you search your library for an enchantment card and put this enchantment into play; you do not play the Enchantment. Tidal Influence has a restriction preventing you from playing it if there is another permanent with the name Tidal Influence in play. However, as you are not playing anything, this restriction does not stop you from putting additional copies in play.
Q: I have an Altar Of Dementia in play and a Protean Hulk. If I sacrifice the Hulk to the Altar, can I use its ability to search for a Vulturous Zombie and bring it into play before my opponent has to mill himself, putting counters on the Zombie?
A: Yes. In fact it is not a choice, that is what will happen. You sacrifice the Protean Hulk when you play Altar of Dementia's ability. This will cause the Hulk's triggered ability to go on the stack on top of the Altar's ability, and it will resolve first. This means that you will search for creature cards and put them into play before your opponent ends up milling cards.
Q: If I play Brainstorm and I have Niv-Mizzet, the Firemind in play, I deal three damage, right?
A: Correct, as you did draw three cards. It does not matter that you end up putting two cards from your hand back on top of your library.
Q: If a creature has flash, what is its card type? I think its just a creature, but a friend of mine said that its an instant and can be countered with spells that say counter target instant spell.
A: A creature with flash is still just a creature card. Your friend is incorrect; the flash ability does not make it an instant. It changes when this creature card can be played; it does not change its card type.
Q: When I am asked to discard a card at random, by what method do I make it random?
A: Any method that you and your opponent can agree upon. I prefer laying the cards in your hand face down, assigning a number to each and rolling a die to pick a random number and re-rolling in the event that the random number is not one that is assigned to a card.





Tuesday, April 22nd - Sealed with Shadowmoor ranges from the ‘worst ever’ when playing against creatures like the Lieges, Rhys the Redeemed, or Godhead of...
Tuesday, April 22nd - With only a month until Standard and Block formats come to dominate the world of Pro Magic, it's easy to lose sight of the reason Magic gets made - it's FUN. Join Rich Hagon for an interactive journey through...
Tuesday, April 22rd - Over two hundred of you submitted terrible, terrible cards that Wizards might print. But today? Today we choose and sort, finding the truly bad cards and choosing... The worst card of all of them. Watch in...
Tuesday, April 22nd - It seems that the Shadowmoor prerelease was a great success across the globe, with eager players casting a myriad of hybrid monsters with...
Tuesday, April 22nd - Tom rocked up to the Shadowmoor prerelease looking to relive the halcyon days of powerful multicolored Limited formats such as Invasion and...
Wednesday, April 23rd - Around Grand Prix: Daytona last year I mentioned that I wanted to write a theory article on Sealed Deck...
Wednesday, April 23rd - I hope you were able to attend the Shadowmoor prerelease this past weekend; here in Richmond, quite a crowd mustered out to get their first taste of the new cards, and first impressions seemed to be that...
Wednesday, April 23rd - It seems that the new set has everyone’s pulse racing, and Benjamin Peebles-Mundy is no exception. Today he shares his prerelease...
Wednesday, April 23rd - Today’s Down And Dirty contains a cautionary tale: do not steal from Kyle Sanchez! In this hilarious article, Mr Sanchez relives some...
Friday, April 18th - Hello everybody, and welcome to another edition of the Magic Show. This week we’re going to be talking about the new nicknames bestowed on...
Friday, April 18th - As with
Friday, April 18th - MTGO is dark. Work has gone so late I couldn’t make drafts on Wednesday or Friday. I haven’t brewed up any decks at all this week –...
Friday, April 18th - Earlier this week, Mike Flores took us through some of his initial thoughts on the exciting Constructed cards on offer in Shadowmoor. Today,...
Friday, April 18th - Tomorrow morning, Magic players worldwide finally get their hands on the new cards from Shadowmoor… and one card in particular is causing...
Friday, April 18th - Want to know which cards will be hot at your prerelease this weekend? Which cards should you pick up now while they are undervalued, and which should you trade away while they are overhyped? Which older card...
Monday, April 21st - We’re kicking things off a little cheekily this week, but that shouldn’t be misconstrued as a bash on any of the other great articles on...
Monday, April 21st - If you're looking for some insight on what Shadowmoor brings to the Legacy scene, then look no further. This week, Adam takes a look at the newest combo to hit Legacy, and how the functional changes to Mox...
Monday, April 21st - Shadowmoor is here, in spirit if not yet in body. Today, Patrick "The Innovator" Chapin takes us through his personal viewpoints on ten of the more exciting cardboard rectangles available in the new set. Do...
Monday, April 21st - The Shadowmoor prerelease is now in the books, and Constructed minds now turn to the strengths and weaknesses of the fresh meat on offer.... 









