Ask the Judge, 5/6/2008
Rules Tip of the Day: All card with the printed card type 'interrupt' are now instants. Any reference to interrupts in a card's text now refers to instants instead.
Q: I have a 1/1 creature with a +1/+1 counter on it, and my opponent plays Puncture Bolt on it. When this creature dies, will it have counters on it or not?
A: Yes, it will. When state-based effects are checked immediately after Puncture Bolt resolves, you have a 1/1 creature with both a +1/+1 and a -1/-1 counter on it and a point of damage. All state-based effects are checked at the same time. So this creature will go to the graveyard due to having lethal damage, and the two counters cease to exist at the exact same time. But just before this creature leaves play, it has counters on it, so effects that care about how many counters it had will 'see' them.
Q: I play Memory Plunder at the end of my opponent's turn targeting Savor the Moment. Do I take the extra turn immediately, or at the end of the upcoming turn?
A: You'll take the turn created by Savor the Moment first, then the turn order will return to normal. This means that this first turn you take will not have an untap step.
Q: If I use Cauldron of Souls on Epochrasite to give it persist before it goes to the graveyard from play, what will happen?
A: It's up to you. Persist and Epocracite's own leaves-play triggered ability will both trigger when Epocrasite goes to the graveyard from play. As the controller of these two abilities, you can choose the order they go on the stack and, therefore, the order they resolve. Whichever ability is put on the top of the stack will resolve first and determine where this Epochrasite ends up. The other ability will resolve, but will be unable to 'find' Epochrasite, as it has left the graveyard. Also, if you choose to have the persist ability return it to play, Epochrasite will come into play with three +1/+1 counters and one -1/-1 counter. One of the +1/+1 counters and the -1/-1 counters will then go away when state-based effects are checked.
Q: I have a friend who likes to play with obscure cards/combos, which create "interesting" game states. His new multiplayer deck uses Nacatl War-Pride with Camouflage. We managed to burn him out of the game in response, but we'd like to know what happens in case he plays it again.
A: The ability of an individual Nacatl War-Pride only applies when blockers are declared, forcing the defending player to block each attacking War-Pride with just one creature if able. However, Camouflage replaces the normal process of choosing blockers. Because of this, the defending player will not have to deal with Nacatl War-Pride blocking requirement / restriction at all. The defending player can choose zero creatures he controls, if he wants, and can end up not blocking at all.
Q: Recently in a game some friends encountered a situation where a Body Double was being brought into play via Living Death and were unsure of what should occur. The player with the Body Double in the graveyard had a few creatures in play, but since those are "set aside" while the Body Double comes into play, we assumed they could not be selected and the Body Double would go to the graveyard as a state-based effect for being a 0/0. Is this correct?
A: No, the controller of the Body Double could choose to have it copy a creature that was in play just before Living Death started resolving. When you resolve Living Death you first take all creature cards in all graveyards and remove them from the game. Then each player will sacrifice all creatures you they have in play. Finally, each player will take the cards that they just removed from the game and put them into play. At this point, when the Body Double is put into play, there are creature cards in a graveyard, and Body Double can come into play as a copy of one of them.
Q: I have a Barbed Shocker attacking and my opponent blocks with a Myr Retriever. When combat damage resolves, does the Shocker's ability go on the stack first, or does the Myr go into the graveyard first, thus making his ability go on the stack first?
A: When combat damage resolves, the Shocker's ability will trigger, but won't go on the stack quite yet. Immediately after this, state-based effects are checked, and the Retriever will go to the graveyard, as it has lethal damage. When it does, its ability will trigger. Then, when a player would receive priority, both of these abilities will go on the stack. Because they are controlled by two different players, they go on the stack in APNAP (Active Player, Non-Active Player) order. This means that the trigger from your Barbed Shocker will go on the stack first and resolve last. In other words, if your opponent does choose to return an artifact card in his graveyard to his hand, it will be discarded when Barbed Shocker's ability resolves.
Q: If I have Vedalken Orrery in play, can use my planeswalker's ability during an opponents turn as well as my own?
A: No. Vedalken Orrery only changes when you can play nonland card; it does not affect the timing of abilities at all.
Q: If I use Karn, Silver Golem's ability to make Lifeline into a creature, and Lifeline leaves play, will it return to play at the end of the turn?
A: Yes, as long as there was another creature in play when the animated Lifeline left play. When that happens, Lifeline's ability will trigger. When this trigger resolves, a delayed triggered ability is created. At the start of the end of turn step, this delayed triggered ability will go on the stack. Lifeline does not have to be in play for this to happen. When this delayed triggered ability resolves, Lifeline will be returned to play.





Wednesday, May 7th - I’m going to talk about how I went about generating a decklist for one of my Hollywood prototypes. The difference is that I’m making no...
Wednesday, May 7th - In case you’ve been under a rock for the past few weeks, you may not know that Star City Games is holding a
Wednesday, May 7th - Which Shadowmoor cards are the best in the world of infinite mana and one spell per turn? As a player of Type 4 you probably want to know what to draft and what sweet new combos to look out for. You’ll get...
Wednesday, May 7th - The Star City Games Mega-Magic Weekend is nearly here, and Benjamin Peebles-Mundy is looking for another Top 8 performance. Today’s...
Thursday, May 8th - MTGO is either going to get fixed, or it is going to die. I don’t see a company like Hasbro letting a profitable asset like MTGO die – I...
Thursday, May 8th - Dave started playing Magic back when people weren’t afraid to eat their steaks raw, weren’t afraid to travel to exotic countries, and stayed away from namby-pamby combo decks. Okay, it was the nineties,...
Thursday, May 8th - Hello all, and welcome back to the Kitchen Table, your weekly column dedicated to all things casual. I am your investigator, searching for...
Thursday, May 8th - In the never-ending quest for fresh Standard decks, Richard Feldman takes a leaf out of the Chapin Playbook today and tries some...
Monday, May 5th - Hello everybody, and welcome to another edition of the Magic Show. In this special Monday Magic Show episode, we talk to Anthony S. Waters and...
Monday, May 5th - I suppose it shouldn’t surprise me anymore, seeing Magic twice in one day while half a world away from home. It’s like running into Brian...
Monday, May 5th - Christopher Coppola analyzes the deck thinning properties of fetchlands and dispels some misconceptions about their
Monday, May 5th - Pro Tour: Hollywood is approaching, and people looking for a little meat in the current Standard environment. While most folk currently dine on...
Monday, May 5th - While the current Vintage metagame is perhaps the most vibrant we’ve ever seen, it’s safe to say that there are a number of core strategies...
Tuesday, May 6th - I’ve been spending most of my time lately trying to create an aggro deck that was close to mono-colored and didn’t get blown out by...
Tuesday, May 6th - It's been a while since we caught up with the fast-moving world of Pro Magic. In his latest update, Rich Hagon examines what went right and... 
Tuesday, May 6th - When we roll up to a large Constructed tournament, we like to think we’re prepared. We’ve quietly and thoroughly honed our deck and... 









