Ask the Judge, 5/7/2008
Rules Tip of the Day: When combat damage is assigned, if all of the creatures that were blocking an attacking creature with trample are no longer in play, then all of the damage from the attacking creature with trample will be assigned to the defending player.
Q: If I have a Ravenous Rats in play and I play Scarscale Ritual, putting the -1/-1 counter on the Rats in order to pay for it, can I play Curfew to return the Rats to my hand before it heads to the graveyard?
A: No. You put a -1/-1 counter on a creature you control as an additional cost to play Scarscale Ritual. Immediately after you play it, state-based effects are checked. At this point, the Ravenous Rats that you put the -1/-1 counter on will be a 0/0 creature and go to the graveyard. This will happen before you can play Curfew, and long before it resolves and you return a creature you control to your hand.
Q:If I use the ability of Inkfathom Witch before blockers are declared, will any creatures have their power and toughness modified?
A: No, because attacking creatures are neither blocked nor unblocked before blockers are declared. That ability can only be used after blockers have been declared.
Q: I'd like to know what happens if I have a Cemetery Puca in play, and someone destroys a Demigod of Revenge I control and I decide to pay one mana to make a copy of the Demigod.
A: The Puca will become a copy of the Demigod. However, the Demigod's ability triggers when you play it as a spell, so this ability of the Puca copy will not trigger.
Q: I have a Leech Bonder in play with two -1/-1 counters on it. What happens to the -1/-1 counters when Godhead of Awe comes into play? Will there still be two counters on Leech Bonder?
A: Yes, but not for long, as the Leech Bonder will go to the graveyard and those counters will cease to exist. The effect from these counters is applied after Godhead of Awe's power- and toughness-setting ability, so the Leech Bonder will end up as a -1/-1 creature and go to the graveyard.
Q: I have a Chronozoa in play and I use Fate Transfer to transfer the vanishing counters to another creature. Would that creature gain vanishing because of the vanishing counters?
A: No. The counters on the Chronozoa are time counters, not vanishing counters. There are no abilities associated with the counters; they are used as an accounting measure.
Q: Can Cairn Wanderer get other abilities that are not listed on the card, such as defender, indestructible, etc.?
A: No. it can only gain the abilities that are listed on the card.
Q: It is my pre-combat main phase. My opponent has a Teferi, Mage of Zhalfir in play. I sacrifice my Windswept Heath and attempt to play Panglacial Wurm from my library. He says I can't, because of Teferi's time restrictions. I believe Panglacial Wurm ignores time restrictions. Am I correct?
A: No. In this example, we have two abilities that contradict each other. The Wurm's ability states that you can play the Wurm at a particular time, and Teferi's ability says that you cannot. Whenever two effects contradict each other, the one that says that something can't happen wins.
Q: I have Mycosynth Lattice in play and I play Tinker. Can I search for a creature card that isn't an artifact at the time and put it into play?
A: No. Mycosynth Lattice makes all cards colorless, but it does not make them into artifacts. This creature card in your library is not an artifact card, so you will not be able to use Tinker to search for it.
Q: Can Hungry Hungry Heifer's ability can be used on suspended cards? Do players actually control suspended cards, and if so, do they count as "cards"?
A: You can own cards in the removed from game zone, but you do not control them. So, no you cannot remove a time counter from a suspended card with Hungry Hungry Heifer.





Thursday, May 8th - MTGO is either going to get fixed, or it is going to die. I don’t see a company like Hasbro letting a profitable asset like MTGO die – I...
Thursday, May 8th - Dave started playing Magic back when people weren’t afraid to eat their steaks raw, weren’t afraid to travel to exotic countries, and stayed away from namby-pamby combo decks. Okay, it was the nineties,...
Thursday, May 8th - Hello all, and welcome back to the Kitchen Table, your weekly column dedicated to all things casual. I am your investigator, searching for...
Thursday, May 8th - In the never-ending quest for fresh Standard decks, Richard Feldman takes a leaf out of the Chapin Playbook today and tries some...
Thursday, May 8th - It appears that the great and good of Star City Games are currently going crazy over Combo decks in Shadowmoor Standard. We’ve had Patrick...
Friday, May 9th - I have spent the past few weeks rambling around the new possibilities with Shadowmoor in Standard, poking around from good idea (Merfolk love...
Friday, May 9th - Hello everybody, and welcome to another edition of the Magic Show. This week we’re going to be delving into the wide-open world of Standard....
Tuesday, May 6th - I’ve been spending most of my time lately trying to create an aggro deck that was close to mono-colored and didn’t get blown out by...
Tuesday, May 6th - It's been a while since we caught up with the fast-moving world of Pro Magic. In his latest update, Rich Hagon examines what went right and... 
Tuesday, May 6th - When we roll up to a large Constructed tournament, we like to think we’re prepared. We’ve quietly and thoroughly honed our deck and...
Wednesday, May 7th - I’m going to talk about how I went about generating a decklist for one of my Hollywood prototypes. The difference is that I’m making no...
Wednesday, May 7th - In case you’ve been under a rock for the past few weeks, you may not know that Star City Games is holding a
Wednesday, May 7th - Which Shadowmoor cards are the best in the world of infinite mana and one spell per turn? As a player of Type 4 you probably want to know what to draft and what sweet new combos to look out for. You’ll get...
Wednesday, May 7th - The Star City Games Mega-Magic Weekend is nearly here, and Benjamin Peebles-Mundy is looking for another Top 8 performance. Today’s... 









