Ask the Judge, 7/15/2008
Rules Tip of the Day: The choice of whether or not to take advantage of a triggered ability that uses the word 'may' is not decided until the triggered ability resolves. If this triggered ability targets, you must choose a target if there is one available as the ability goes on the stack, even if you do not plan on choosing to have the ability take effect.
Q: I play Snakeform and target Chameleon Colossus, and in response, my opponent pumps Chameleon Colossus using his ability. Will the 1/1 green Snake still be a 1/1 green Snake after the pump resolves and Snakeform resolves, or will he be a 5/5 green Snake?
A: It will be a 1/1 green Snake. The increased power and toughness given by Chameleon Colossus's ability is calculated when the ability resolves and is locked in. In this example, the power of the Colossus is four when the ability resolves, so the Colossus will get +4/+4. However, the effect from Snakeform is applied in the same layer, and the timestamp from this effect will be later than the one from Chameleon Colossus's ability. This means when calculating its P/T you start with a 4/4 Chameleon Colossus, it becomes an 8/8, and then finally a 1/1.
Q: If I have an Avalanche Riders and a Cauldron of Souls in play at the beginning of my upkeep, can I put echo on the stack, give the Riders persist with the Cauldron, choose not to pay the echo and sacrifice the Riders, and then have the Riders return to play with a -1/-1 counter to destroy another land?
A: Yes, that works. Keep in mind that you will have to pay echo in the upkeep step of your next turn or sacrifice the Riders.
Q: Can Plated Slagwurm be named for Runed Halo?
A: Yes. Choosing a card name when Runed Halo comes into play does not target anything.
Q: I have Mana Reflection and Lotus Petal in play. When I tap and sacrifice the Lotus Petal, do I get two mana?
A: Yes. Lotus Petal's mana ability does have you tap it, so Mana Reflection's ability is applied. It does not matter that you also sacrifice the Petal.
Q: If I have a Horde of Notions in play and choose to use the Horde's activated ability to play a Cloudthresher from my graveyard, is the Cloudthresher counterable?
A: Yes. When Horde of Notions' ability resolves, you can play the targeted Elemental card. This card is played as a spell and it can be countered by effects that counter spells.
Q: I have a Pyromancer's Swath in play, and an Ignite Memories targeting my opponent. If my opponent reveals a land, does it do two damage or zero damage from the Ignite Memories, plus two damage from the Swath? Or does doing zero damage not exist?
A: No damage will be dealt. Pyromancer's Swath only increases the amount of damage that would be dealt if damage would actually be dealt. If a land card is chosen from yoru opponent's hand this means that zero damage is being dealt, so the effect from the Swath will not be applied.
Q: If I play Surge of Zeal on a legal target, like a red creature I control, and I play red creatures after it resolves in the same turn, do the other red creatures have haste, even if they were not there when I cast the spell?
A: No. The effect from Surge of Zeal only affects those creatures that shared a color with the targeted creature and were in play when Surge of Zeal resolved. Creatures that enter play after Surge of Zeal resolves will not be affected, even if they do share a color with the creature that was targeted.
Q: I have random enchantments in my graveyard along with Copy Enchantment, but no enchantments in play already, and I cast Replenish, will I be able to choose one of those enchantments to copy with Copy Enchantment?
A: No. All of these enchantments return to play at the same time. You choose an enchantment in play for Copy Enchantment to copy as it comes into play, which means before any of these enchantments are actually in play. If you cannot choose a copy, then Copy Enchantment will still enter play, but as itself, which for the most part does nothing.
Q: I was recently at a local Vintage tournament when a bizarre interaction came up. The interaction in question was between Word of Command and the opponent's Yawgmoth's Will. Player A had used Word to "steal" the Will, and was curious if he essentially gained access to control of his opponent's graveyard as a result.
A: No. He can make his opponent play his Yawgmoth's Will, but that just means that his opponent will be able to play cards from his graveyard that turn. The player that plays Word of Command does not gain control of a card they force an opponent to play. This spell is still controlled by its owner.
Q: If a creature blocking The Wretched dies, will that creature go to the player controlling The Wretched?
A: No, you only gain control of those creatures if they are still in play at the end of combat after blocking The Wretched. The Wretched's ability only affects creatures, it does not bring creature cards back into play.





Wednesday, July 16th - The Eventide spoiler is out, and ‘tis the season for set reviews. While you’ll be getting the Spike-side view from the Premium gang,...
Wednesday, July 16th - A key element of the “acquisition process” that, it appears, has been one of WoTC’s many buzzwords for 2008, is making the process...
Wednesday, July 16th - Eventide is here (in theory), and everyone is looking for a Limited edge in the new and upcoming format. Today, Pro Tour Top 8 competitor Marijn Lybaert brings us the thoughts from the Belgian jury, with...
Wednesday, July 16th - With Eventide fresh in everyone’s minds, and the Constructed applications of the new cards and mechanics slowly filtering through our collective unconsciousness, Benjamin Peebles-Mundy takes a break from...
Thursday, July 17th - Life’s been a little busy lately, and I was not going to write an article this week. The prerelease was – from my perspective – sort of blah. Then I read both Chatter’s article this week, and the...
Thursday, July 17th - Today’s article is the third installment of The Magic Role-Playing Game. The last article was published back in January, so I felt it was...
Thursday, July 17th - What do a stairway taller than the Empire State Building, a too-long lunch at Long John Silver’s, and a fourth Tarmogoyf have in common? ... 
Friday, July 18th - We have been toiling in what seems to be a degenerate Block Constructed format, living in a world where Faeries wins more than half the PTQs,...
Monday, July 14th - With the prerelease behind us, it’s time to rattle through the completed card list and pick out those card that inspire innovation....
Monday, July 14th - A full 189 players showed up to do battle for a slot to Berlin on the Fifth of July. After just a few rounds we...
Monday, July 14th - This story begins with an announcement that was posted on The Source by Chris Lennon (Volt) advertising a Legacy tournament in Vancouver, WA. People start discussing the possibility about driving out to the...
Monday, July 14th - Eventide is here, in spirit if not quite in body. With the Block Constructed PTQ season continuing apace, and Standard gaining relevance due...
Tuesday, July 15th - Today I’ll be going over some thoughts on Eventide, and its impact on Block and possibly Standard. I’ll also recap some of my thoughts...
Tuesday, July 15th - This past weekend, in my continuing effort to qualify for Pro Tour: Berlin, I traveled to Detroit for a PTQ. I decided that for the rest of...
Tuesday, July 15th - Many believe that everyone has a Purpose in life, a true Reason they are called upon to walk the Earth. Many of us have pondered what...
Tuesday, July 15th - We all had fun at the Eventide prerelease this past weekend, but now it’s time to knuckle down to the serious work of evaluating the new... 









