Please hold while we load your cart...
The Non-Cheat Sheet
Here is the latest version of my judge cheat sheet, updated for the new Penalty Guidelines that take effect on September 20.
It's slightly smaller than credit-card-sized, to leave a little room for lamination and still fit in your wallet. To print ideally, download, use a duplex color printer and select the print option to center on the page.
Random Thoughts
- On the bottom of the side with the Penalty Guidelines is a little guide to writing your penalties down for optimum entry into DCI Reporter, right down to the oddity of the judge's name being "First Last" and the player's name being "Last, First".
- The other side consists of a couple of synopses of key sections of the rules, things that I've found are the most common things that judges refer to when they look for the Comprehensive Rules. In particular, layers + copying handle a lot of the most common questions in current formats (Hello, Snakeform!).
- Is it really cheating to carry easily-looked-up reference material around? Not really. It's common practice at higher level tournaments for judges to have their own version of the penalty guidelines in their pocket, and in some cases, the head judge will even bring copies to provide to floor judges. While it's important to know the rules and guidelines yourself, having a reference can help with the ultimate goal—getting the rulings right. As a bonus, actually looking things up quickly can increase your credibility with players without costing much, if any, time.
- This is not, and should not be construed to be, a full reference. It's intended to be a quick reminder that will only make sense in the full context of the rules (for example, there are more details than can be summarized entirely in a small space, and some detailed points are left out of the synopses). Having access to a quick reference is not a sufficient substitute for a real understanding of the rules, and if you haven't taken the time to refresh yourself on the full rules lately, it's worth the time to do so.
- Don't let your references get stale! It's very common for people to hang onto these things for too long, and it's important to remember that the state of the art in DCI policy keeps changing, and there are adjustments that are made to the Penalty Guidelines every three months. Remember to check for the quarterly updates to the Penalty Guidelines and make sure to update or discard your cheat sheet if it isn't up-to-date anymore.
Wrapping Up
If you have any issues with the cheat sheet, whether it be content, printing, or anything else, feel free to post in the forums and I'll do my best to help. Suggestions are also welcome, and I'll do my best to fulfill customization requests as well.
Next month: Initial thoughts as we all venture into the brave new world of the Wizards Play Network, and how it affects Prerelease Tournaments.
---
Nicholas J. Fang
DCI Certified Level 3 Judge—Redmond, WA
mtgjudge@live.com
Agbaar and Ag|Work on EFnet's #mtgjudge
Friday, September 12th - Canadian draft maestro Rich Hoaen takes us for a stroll through an 8-4 Shadowmoor / Eventide draft on Magic Online, from pick 1 to pick... 
Monday, September 15th - “What was it like, being locked in with some of the finest writers in science fiction for six weeks?” you may ask. And the answer... 
Monday, September 15th - School is starting, the leaves are changing colors, and Notre Dame almost loses its home opener to a team that lost to Cal Poly the week before. That can only mean one thing: that it’s fall and the... 
Monday, September 15th - With Patrick Chapin nursing his wounds over in Rimini, today we have the exciting conclusion of Marijn Lybaert’s Belgian Nationals... 
Monday, September 15th - Shards of Alara is just around the corner, and one officially spoiled card in particular is kicking up a Vintage stink: Tezzeret the... 
Tuesday, September 16th - I think it’s a touch too soon to talk about Extended, so this week we’ll be discussing some Vintage ramifications from the Time... 
Thursday, September 11th - With a Limited PTQ season looming large, it’s time for those players with a purely Constructed bent to retreat into their shells and cook up some sixty-card excitement. Continuing his promise to pilot... 
Friday, September 12th - Hello everybody, and welcome to another edition of the Magic Show. This week we’re featuring the Magic Show exclusive new Magic Player Rewards card, talk about the return of States with the man... 
Friday, September 12th - With most of Extended a 'known quantity,’ the potential impact of Shards of Alara remains generally small. We have been told already that all of the creatures from the shard of Esper will be artifact... 
Friday, September 12th - Shards of Alara is almost here, and this will herald a two-block and one base set rotation out of Extended. Gone will be seven full... 
Friday, September 12th - Mike Flores, in his famous "Who’s The Beatdown?" article, told us that "Misassignment of Role = Game Loss." However, words such as "Role" can be notoriously nebulous… Role is not Archetype. Today,... 
