Mono-Black In Pauper
Untap play a Swamp win the game.
Seems like a pretty good reason to be playing black.
In the history of Pauper one of the scariest things a black deck can do is continue to play lands. Swamps represent an endgame in the form of Corrupt or Consume Spirit. Swamps represent a huge swing in tempo thanks to Tendrils of Corruption.
Black creatures are also some of the best available—not because of their ability to inflict damage but because they are actually spells with bodies. Long before Mulldrifter changed the world of creatures forever black mages were whipping Chittering Rats and Gravediggers into play (it wasn't the battlefield back then and we had to walk three miles in the snow uphill to get there) providing disruption and card advantage. The fact that black played well with more black cards drove these decks to monochromatic status setting the stage for some of the best game-ending spells available to Pauper.
Why run black in the first place? Sure disruption is good and so are big game-ending spells but why has Mono-Black experienced prolonged success in a format ruled by commons? The truth is black has the ability to handle just about everything Pauper can throw at it and it handles it on the cheap as well.
Taking a step back the best decks in Pauper for the majority of the format's history have been creature-based strategies; even now the top combo deck relies heavily on creatures. Since the earliest days of Magic black has been the best at killing creatures with commons. Being able to remove an opponent's creature for half or even a quarter of the cost of their investment can generate a massive advantage. Removing the second third and fourth while building towards your own endgame without any investment aside from a land drop is not the fairest thing in the world. And this is possible thanks to Limited.
Every set needs black removal at common to help push black's color identity and help balance draft. This creates an abundance of quality removal at common so if you are running black you have access during deckbuilding to the right answers for the metagame's threats. Selecting the right removal is one of the first challenges in building a proper black deck.
Tendrils of Corruption is a marquee Pauper spell. It undoes more than one turn if cast for four—the time and mana invested in a creature as well as at least one previous attack. Black is not the fastest color out there and the tempo swing provided by a resolved Tendrils often provides the buffer required to overwhelm an opponent with Rats and Corrupt. Tendrils is at its best in metagames featuring non-Goblin aggro and other midrange decks. While Tendrils is not a dead card against Goblins (you can always aim it at your own men for a life boost) the combination of Goblin Sledder and Mogg Raider makes Tendrils an overpriced Terror. Tendrils functions similarly against Affinity if they have a sacrifice outlet (Atog or Krark-Clan Shaman) on the table. If White Weenie is expecting black then the four-mana tempo swing is a bad call since they will likely be packing Order of Leitbur and Guardian of the Guildpact in addition Benevolent Bodyguard. That being said running Tendrils is almost always correct because even resolving it once can generate an immense advantage.
Doom Blade is a great catchall but is currently out of favor. While it does handle a large number of creatures the fact that it cannot hit black creatures is a huge burden. First Mono-Black is prevalent and running four live cards fewer than your opponent is just a mistake. On top of that the top deck runs on an engine that is partially fueled by a black creature; the fact that under no circumstances will a Doom Blade take out a Nightscape Familiar means that the Blade of Doom needs to ride the pine.
Unmake answers everything but exiling a creature does not really matter in Pauper and there are cheaper options.
Disfigure is at its best when you are expecting an abundance of aggressive strategies. Being able to pick off a turn 1 Goblin or early Frogmite can be critical to surviving long enough to win. Last Gasp and Grasp of Darkness fill similar rolls with Grasp being the better of the rhyming couplet as for the same price it takes out more creatures. Echoing Decay fills a special niche for MBC helping to fight token strategies and being an effective answer to Empty the Warrens.
Innocent Blood Diabolic Edict and Geth's Verdict all fill similar rolls helping to take out otherwise impossible-to-kill creatures. When control decks rely on singular threats these spells see heavy play. Innocent Blood used to see more play as a turn 1 answer but since the printing of Disfigure those instances are few and far between in aggro-heavy metas.
Ghastly Demise and Vendetta are both narrow one-mana answers. The life payment on Vendetta is too high a risk in an environment with as many aggressive decks as Pauper displays and Ghastly Demise is not as strong early negating the efficiency of a one-mana spell.
Finally Snuff Out while available rarely sees play in Mono-Black Control. The fact that the deck does not often tap out except to win means that paying four life to take out a beater is not a value play. Why spend four life when MBC can cast a Rat and leave mana up for a two-mana kill spell? The lack of play however may also be attributed to the scarcity of Snuff Out—released in Duel Decks the cost is prohibitive to some players.
These are the removal options for MBC but they represent only a portion of the answers. The appeal of MBC also runs into the realm of discard and land destruction. When the top decks are combo the ability to take out lands and pivotal spells can buy time.
The discard spells of choice vary between Duress and Distress with the former relegated to sideboard status. Distress while slower can take out all the key spells of Frantic Storm excluding lands. In a format where creatures matter whiffing on a Duress is a liability.
The value of turns is one of the reasons that land destruction is often left in the sideboard. While Choking Sands Icequake or Rancid Earth on a key turn can be devastating to Frantic Storm these cards look downright foolish on turn 3 against Goblins or Burn. Perhaps the “best” spell in this category is Befoul but that is because it serves double duty as a removal spell albeit a glacial one.
The biggest strike against the black land death package is that it costs three mana and this is when black wants to be playing Rats.
And by Rats I mean creatures with enters-the-battlefield abilities. These creatures are at the core of Mono-Black and help in the denial game plan. The only creature that is in every build is Chittering Rats. Its ability is so much more than discard; it is the denial of a draw step. However the Rats must be played properly. The goal is not to run it out on turn 3 every time but to cast it when it will do the most damage. The end result is to take away the draw step that is most needed: the turn before they combo off or the turn before they are setting up to swing for the win. Oftentimes this is playing it right on turn 3 as most decks are still starting their game plan at that point. If your opponent is sculpting a key turn it is time to play Rats. If they are doing nothing it is probably correct to hold the Rats back.
The other “Rats” like the removal all depend on the expected field. Ravenous Rats are at their best when they can block and soak up damage. Very strong against Goblins and Affinity they lose their luster against combo but still have utility. Another popular two-drop is Augur of Skulls for times when games are expected to go long and there will be a need to take out two cards. At the same time Augur does a better job blocking larger threats as it can regenerate.
In the three-drop slot Liliana's Specter and Phyrexian Rager vie for spots. Specter is more useful when you want to take away options from the bad guys and Rager is better when you want more options on your end. Personally I try to make space for both but there are times when maxing out on one is correct. Cadaver Imp also sees play but not as much mostly due to the fact that it costs too much for one power. However it passes the Unearth test.
Unearth is a vital card in the new MBC. The old plan was to play Gravedigger or Warren Pilferers to rebuy creatures but Unearth is far cheaper. Being able to get a second use out of a Rat at a reduced cost allows for turns where you can Rats twice setting an opponent back two cards. Considering that Mono-Black's game plan is to nip and gain every edge it can leaving mana up for removal while playing a disruptive threat generates a decent swing.
The final “Rat” that gets consideration is Okiba-Gang Shinobi. Part Blighting and part Unearth the Ninja shines against control and traditional Storm but does not do anything against the Frantic deck as they are highly redundant and have access to Deep Analysis main to combat discard. Shinobi represents a swing of at least three cards—the two lost from the first hit and then the second card from the returned Rat. When the Gang is good it is great but when it is wrong it is a liability.
Crypt Rats is the other creature that sees regular play. One of the best sweepers in the format it can answer almost every creature that hits the board but at the same time can put its controller at a perilously low life total. Normally MBC will have enough removal that it can survive without Crypt Rats main relegating them to the bench. However sometimes the deck must skew towards other forms of disruption making the mini-Wrath pull its weight as the primary removal option.
The conundrum of Mono-Black is that it can answer everything. The discard the land destruction the removal and the creatures to which black has access give Swamp things the ability to meet the format where it is that day. The problem is packing the right sixty. In a format where Guardian of the Guildpact is the threat of choice bringing Grasp of Darkness is going to look mighty foolish. Tendrils of Corruption is fantastic unless everyone has Goblins. MBC is a deck that requires an intestine and intimate knowledge of the expected metagame. The right list can easily go undefeated; the wrong list can just as easily go 0-2 drop.
Here is a sample list I use. This list was built with Affinity and combo in mind moving many of the answers to Goblins to the sideboard:
- 24 Swamp
The goal with this deck is to grind out the opponent taking away cards and threats and whittling away a life total until Corrupts can be chained together for a dominating victory.
This is by no means a definitive list but is a good starting point for people looking to exploit the power of Swamps.
Keep slingin' commons-
SpikeBoyM on MTGO
@nerdtothecore on Twitter