• STORE
  • EVENTS
  • ARTICLES
  • NEWS
  • DECKS
  • BUYLIST
  • HELP
Advanced Search
Deck Builder
  • Hello. Sign In.
    YOUR ACCOUNT

    forgot your password?

    New customer? Start here!

  • CART

    View Cart ( items)

    Checkout

  • WISH
    LIST
       
  • Magic Singles
    • English
    • Foil English
    • Non-English
    • Foil Non-English
    • BGS/Graded Cards
    • Complete Sets
    • Misprints and Rarities
    • Wholesale Lots
  • Magic Sealed Product
    • Expansion Sets
    • Booster Packs
    • Booster Boxes
    • Starter & Tourn. Packs
    • Starter & Tourn. Displays
    • Theme Decks
    • Event Decks
    • Intro Packs
    • Fat Packs
    • Two-Player Games
    • Standalone Sets
    • Archenemy
    • Commander
    • Duel Decks
    • From the Vault
    • Planechase
    • Premium Deck Series
    • Misc. Box Sets
    • Non-English Sealed
  • Gaming Supplies
    • Binders
    • Books & Fat Pack Guides
    • Boxes & Bags
    • Clothing
    • Deck Boxes
    • Dice
    • Life Counters
    • Playmats
    • Sleeves
  • Specialty Items
    • Ascension
    • Gift Cards
    • Lithographs
    • Original Artwork
  • Digital Products
    • Grinder: The Brad Nelson Story
    • Next Level Magic
    • OMG: Official Miser's Guide
    • Tha Gatherin'
  • We Buy

Ask the Judge, 02/16/2004

Sheldon Menery
2/16
  •  
  •  

Q: So, my question is how Vernal Bloom and Pulse of the Llanowar interact. Vernal Bloom says: Whenever a Forest is tapped for mana, its controller adds G to his or her mana pool. Pulse of the Llanowar says: If a basic land you control is tapped for mana, it produces mana of any one color instead of its normal type.

So if I am trying to get Blue mana from my Forests, does each Forest produce GU, or UU? And whichever it does, why does it do it that way?

A: Pulse of Llanowar's replacement effect lets you get any color mana from your Forest. Vernal Bloom's mana-triggered ability adds green no matter what color you got from the Forest, because that's what it's ability says. You'd get GU.

Q: If I have a Heartseeker in play that allows me to kill a creature by un-attaching Heartseeker. My question is: If my creature is affected by summoning sickness, can I use the Heartseeker to kill his creature or must I wait until my turn?

A: Heartseeker grants an ability to the creature. Note it says"...gains <ability>." That means it's the creature's ability and not the artifact's. You can't tap it yet.

Q: I have a Mogg Maniac in play. My opponent enchants my Mogg Maniac with Pariah. Any damage done to my opponent is redirected to my Mogg Maniac, but when my Mogg Maniac takes damage, it does an equal amount of damage to my opponent. Would Pariah then redirect that damage back to my Mogg Maniac? Does my Mogg Maniac die at some point and break this seemingly infinite loop?

I guess what I'm really asking is, what happens when my opponent takes damage?

A: Mogg Maniac has a triggered ability; Pariah has a replacement effect. Pariah replaces damage done to your opponent with damage done to the Maniac. The Maniac will take X damage and trigger. Before we put that trigger on the stack, we check State-Based Effects. The Maniac is put into the graveyard, and then the Pariah sees that it's not enchanting anything and be put into the 'yard as well. Then the Maniac's ability will resolve, damaging your opponent. The Pariah is no longer around to replace that damage.

Q: I was actually playing a game over lunch today, using a new Modular deck I worked up. An opponent in our two-headed giant game played Patriarch's Bidding. He claimed that since the Arcbound cards were simply"Artifact Creature", they had no Creature Type and could not be returned to play.

A: Your opponent was correct. Not all artifact creatures have a creature type (Myr do, as do some Golems, plus a few others)."Artifact" is not a creature type and can't be named for Patriarch's Bidding.

Q: I have a face-down Skirk Marauder in play. During my opponent's turn, he plays Noxious Ghoul. After the ghoul resolves, I morph my Skirk Marauder and deal two damage to his 3/3 token. Does my marauder get to deal the two damage before dying?

A: Yes. Its ability will trigger on it being turned face up. Before that trigger goes on the stack, you check State-Based Effects, and put the Skirk in the graveyard. The triggered ability will still resolve.

Q: I have Carrionette in my graveyard. I activate Carrionette's ability targeting my opponent's Withered Wretch. He responds by using Wretch's ability on the Carrionette.

A: The ability still resolves, removing your opponent's creature. Removing Carrionette isn't a condition of removing the creature.

Q: I was under the impression that Oblation didn't allow the owner to draw two cards if it targets a token, since it could not be shuffled into the library. The card states,"....shuffles it into his or her library, then draws two cards." Since the two sentence fragments are joined by"then," and a token cannot be shuffled into a library, I would think the clause is not met and the two cards cannot be drawn, since the effect does not proceed to that stage. Is this correct?

A: The card draw isn't contingent on a physical card being shuffled back into the deck. So long as the target is still legal on resolution, the entire ability will resolve. You'll shuffle nothing into your deck and then draw two cards.

Q: I was wondering if the following combo works as I think it does: Geth's Grimoire plus Words of Waste.

Provided I have the mana, does it allow me to empty my opponent's hand ? If so how much does it cost me to empty his whole hand (seven)?

A: Yes. Words of Waste has a replacement effect, Geth's Grimoire is triggered. You can activate it for each card you would draw, making the opponent discard, triggering the Grimoire, replacing that, and so on. It will cost you one for each card you want him to discard. Remember, the Words' ability must be resolve before you would draw the card.

Q: Can you launder mana? For instance, Thran Turbine states that you can add two colorless mana, but that mana cannot be used to play spells. If you pass the mana through a Chromatic Sphere, can you cast a spell with it?

A: Sure. You've used the Thran Turbine mana to activate an ability, not to play a spell. When the activated ability resolves, the mana knows it came directly from the Chromatic Sphere.

Q: Will activating my Isochron Scepter with a spell imprinted on it count for:

a) Untapping my Pristine Angel

b) Putting a charge counter on my opponent's Chimeric Egg.

A: a) Yes. You're playing a spell.

b) Yes, so long as it's not an artifact spell (you never know, there might someday be an Artifact Instant with CMC of 2 or less).

Q: Are the charge counters, like those generated by a Coretapper the same as fade counters, like those on a Saproling Burst?

A: No. Counters with different names are not interchangeable.

  •  
  •  
« Previous Article
Vintage -- Time Walk: The Debate Rages!
Next Article »
Ask the Judge, 02/17/2004

About Sheldon Menery

Judge Emeritus Sheldon Menery is one of the most influential judges in the history of the game. He popularized Magic Q&A here on SCG with "Ask the Judge" and was a leading force in redefining fair play at the professional level. He pioneered Commander and is the public face of the format. He has Head Judged countless Pro Tours, World Championships, and Grand Prix and has played in five National Championships. He lives in Tampa, Florida with his wife Gretchyn and their five cats: Dasher, Cupid, Comet, Vito, and Vixen.

SheldonMenery

Read more by
Sheldon Menery



ORGANIZED PLAY
  • THIS WEEKEND
  • NEXT WEEKEND
  • +
  • THIS Saturday, June 22
  • OPEN Philadelphia, PA
  • Super IQ Richmond, KY - Cosmic Oasis
  • IQ Roanoke, VA - Star City Game Center
  • IQ Lafayette, IN - The Game Preserve
  • IQ Biloxi, MS - Jak's
  • IQ Lutherville/Timonium, MD - Titan Games & Hobbies
  • IQ Tallahassee, FL - Gamescape
  • IQ St. Louis, MO - Ogres Games
  • THIS Sunday, June 23
  • OPEN Philadelphia, PA
  • IQ Sellersburg, IN - Silver Creek Game Shop
  • Friday, June 28
  • GP Miami, FL - StarCityGames.com
  • Saturday, June 29
  • GP Miami, FL - StarCityGames.com
  • Super IQ Indian Trail, NC - Be There Games
  • IQ Arbutus, MD - Xanadu Games
  • IQ Midlothian, VA - Richmond Comix
  • IQ Tupelo, MS - Tupelo Sportscards
  • IQ Stroudsburg, PA - The Gamer's Edge
  • IQ Normandy Park, WA - Card Advantage Games
  • IQ Farmingdale, NY - Empire Gaming & Comics
  • IQ Warren, OH - All American Comics
  • IQ Oxford, AL - FCB Games and Comics
  • Sunday, June 30
  • GP Miami, FL - StarCityGames.com
  • IQ Harrisburg, PA - The Adventurer's Guild
  • IQ Columbia, TN - Collector's Alley
  • IQ Abingdon, MD - Critical Hit Games
  • IQ Carson City, NV - Dk's Sierra Mountian Comics
  • IQ Hatboro, PA - Stomping Grounds
  • IQ Poughkeepsie, NY - Dragon's Den
  • IQ Lenexa, KS - Collector's Cache
  • IQ Lynchburg, VA - Untamed Worlds
  • IQ Dover, DE - Scarecrow Games
  • IQ Fond du Lac, WI - The Mana Vault

STARCITYGAMES.COM EVENTS

  • Jun 22-23: OPEN Philadelphia, PA
  • Jun 28-30: GRAND PRIX Miami, FL
  • Jul 6-7: OPEN Worcester, MA
  • Jul 20-21: OPEN Richmond, VA
  • Jul 20: CLASSIC Lansing, MI
  • Jul 26-28: INVITATIONAL Somerset, NJ
  • Aug 3-4: OPEN Minneapolis, MN
  • Aug 3: CLASSIC Knoxville, TN
  • Aug 10-11: OPEN Salt Lake City
  • Aug 10: CLASSIC Albany, NY

ELITE QUALIFIERS

  • THIS WEEK: See all Open Trials

EVENT FINDER

  • Complete SCG Schedule - Coverage Archive
NEWS
  • 6/17 YMTC 4 Art Descriptions!
  • 6/17 Weekend Results! June 15-16
  • 6/14 2013 MTGO Community Cup!
  • 6/14 WoW TCG comes to the Open Series!
  • 6/12 Team Sealed in Richmond for M14!
  • 6/11 New Worcester Formats For Theros...
  • 6/10 Weekend Results, June 8-9
  • 6/10 Liz Nugent Lithographs!
  • 6/7 SCG Presents: TURTLES!
  • 6/7 SCG 2013 Platinum Pros!
  • 6/5 MTGO Announcements
  • 6/3 Weekend Results! June 1-2
  • View All News Items - Submit Magic News
DECKLISTS
  • STANDARD
  • LEGACY
  • MODERN
  • 6/16 SCG Open Columbus, US
  • 6/16 MTGO Daily Event
  • 6/09 SCG Elite IQ Durham, US
  • 6/09 MTGO Premier Event
  • 6/09 SCG Open St. Louis, US
  • 6/08 Invi Qualifier Ooltewah, US
  • 6/02 Invi Qualifier Staten Island, US
  • 6/02 Pro Tour Qualifier Hollywood, US
  • 6/02 SCG Open Baltimore, US
  • 6/02 Invi Qualifier Kansas City, US
  • 6/02 MTGO Daily Event
  • 6/01 Invi Qualifier Columbus, US
View More Standard Decks - Search Decklists
  • 5/19 SCG Super IQ Milano, US
  • 5/12 Grand Prix Portland, US
  • 4/07 Invi Qualifier Glen Burnie, US
  • 3/17 Grand Prix San Diego, US
  • 3/17 Pro Tour Qualifier Melbourne, AU
  • 3/10 MTGO Daily Event
  • 3/10 Pro Tour Qualifier Magic Online,
  • 3/03 Pro Tour Qualifier Philadelphia, US
  • 3/03 Pro Tour Qualifier Toronto, CA
  • 3/03 Pro Tour Qualifier Madison, US
  • 3/03 Pro Tour Qualifier Magic Online,
  • 3/03 Pro Tour Qualifier West Nyack, US
View More Modern Decks - Search Decklists
  • 6/16 SCG Open Columbus, US
  • 6/09 SCG Open St. Louis, US
  • 6/02 SCG Open Baltimore, US
  • 5/19 Invi Qualifier Columbus, US
  • 5/19 SCG Open Nashville,
  • 5/19 SCG Open Nashville, US
  • 5/12 Annecy, FR
  • 4/21 SCG Open Seattle, US
  • 4/14 SCG Open Milwaukee, US
  • 4/14 Invi Qualifier Bristol, US
  • 4/07 SCG Invitational Atlanta, US
  • 4/07 SCG Open Atlanta, US
View More Legacy Decks - Search Decklists
SOCIAL

StarCityGames.com on Facebook


StarCityGames.com on Twitter

Join the conversation


WEEKLY NEWSLETTER

Exclusive Deals & Content Every Week



 

ACCOUNT
  • Login/Register
  • My Account
  • Order History
  • Credit History
  • Wishlists
  • Premium
  • Digital Items
  • Gift Card Redemption
CONTACT US
  • Customer Service/Order Issues
  • Advertising
  • Articles
  • Game Center
  • Gift Cards
  • Inventory Issues
  • Organized Play
  • SCG Premium
  • Selling to SCG
  • Shipping
  • Submit News
  • Website Bugs/Problems
ORDER QUESTIONS
  • Customer Service Hours
    Monday through Friday
    10AM - 6PM EST
    Ph: (540) 767-GAME (4263)
  • Email
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Refund/Return Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Statement
  • About StarCityGames.com
SCG ORGANIZED PLAY
  • Overview
  • Schedule
  • Coverage Archives
  • Invitational Qualifiers
  • Host an Invitational Qualifier
  • Judge Rewards
  • Open Points
  • Standings
  • SCGLive
GAME CENTER
  • Star City Game Center
    5728 Williamson Road N.W.
    Roanoke, VA 24012
    Ph: (540) 767-GAME(4263)
  • Email
  • Hours & Info
ARCHIVES
  • Search our Articles
  • Coverage Archives
  • RSS Feed
MORE SCG
  • SCGMobile
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Newsletter
  • SCGLive
  • TheManaDrain.com
  • CubeDrafting.com
All original content on this page is © 2012 StarCityGames.com and may not be used or reproduced without consent. Wizards of the Coast, Magic: The Gathering, and their logos are trademarks of Wizards of the Coast LLC. © 2012 Wizards. All rights reserved. StarCityGames.com is not affiliated with Wizards of the Coast LLC.