• STORE
  • EVENTS
  • ARTICLES
  • NEWS
  • DECKS
  • BUYLIST
  • HELP
Advanced Search
Deck Builder
  • Hello. Sign In.
    YOUR ACCOUNT

    forgot your password?

    New customer? Start here!

  • CART

    View Cart ( items)

    Checkout

  • WISH
    LIST
       
  • Magic Singles
    • English
    • Foil English
    • Non-English
    • Foil Non-English
    • BGS/Graded Cards
    • Complete Sets
    • Misprints and Rarities
    • Wholesale Lots
  • Magic Sealed Product
    • Expansion Sets
    • Booster Packs
    • Booster Boxes
    • Starter & Tourn. Packs
    • Starter & Tourn. Displays
    • Theme Decks
    • Event Decks
    • Intro Packs
    • Fat Packs
    • Two-Player Games
    • Standalone Sets
    • Archenemy
    • Commander
    • Duel Decks
    • From the Vault
    • Planechase
    • Premium Deck Series
    • Misc. Box Sets
    • Non-English Sealed
  • Gaming Supplies
    • Binders
    • Books & Fat Pack Guides
    • Boxes & Bags
    • Clothing
    • Deck Boxes
    • Dice
    • Life Counters
    • Playmats
    • Sleeves
  • Specialty Items
    • Ascension
    • Gift Cards
    • Lithographs
    • Original Artwork
  • Digital Products
    • Grinder: The Brad Nelson Story
    • Next Level Magic
    • OMG: Official Miser's Guide
    • Tha Gatherin'
  • We Buy

Ask the Judge, 03/15/2004

Sheldon Menery
3/15
  •  
  •  

Q: I have Pristine Angel in play, and I attack with it. My opponent activates his Royal Assassin to destroy it. In response, I play an Instant and untap my Angel. Is it still destroyed because the Assassin's ability is already on the stack?

A: No. As with all targeted spells and abilities, when the Royal Assassin's ability goes to resolve, it will check to make sure its target is still legal. It's not, so the ability will be countered on resolution (rule 413.2a).

Q: I have two Frogmites in play, one equipped with Mask of Memory. I attack with both, and my opponent uses his Pearl Shard on himself. Do I get to draw my cards?

A: Not if your opponent doesn't want you to. Because all the damage is being dealt simultaneously, he can choose which he prevents.

Q: My opponent has a creature equipped with Skullclamp. I play Murderous Spoils targeting the creature. Who gets to draw the cards?

A: Your opponent draws the cards. He controlled the Skullclamp when the creature was put into the graveyard, during the first part of the resolution of Murderous Spoils. You don't get control of the Skullclamp until afterward.

Q: I understand that if I target my opponent's creature with the ability from Sword of Fire and Ice, and he sacrifices the creature in response, I do not get to draw a card because the entire ability is countered on resolution because its only target is invalid (your often-quoted rule 413.2a). Does this same situation occur with Sword of Light and Shadow? If the creature card in the graveyard is removed before resolution (like with Scrabbling Claws), would I still gain 3 life?

A: Yes, it's the same. The triggered ability has a single target. If the target is invalid on resolution, the entire ability is countered, so there's no card draw.

Q: Just what the heck is a charge counter?

A: A counter is a marker placed on an object, either modifying its characteristics or interacting with an effect."Charge" is just a name for a particular type of counter. All counters of the same name are interchangeable. There are also age, bomb, flood, fuse, and spore counters, to name a few, along with several counter variants that modify a creature's power and toughness.

Q: If you play Reap and Sow to put a Cloudpost (or any other land with the text"comes into play tapped" on it) into play, does it come into play tapped or not?

A: It comes into play tapped. A permanent that states it comes into play tapped will come into play that way regardless of how it gets there.

Q: What happens when you play Echoing Courage targeting Gemini Engine with the token already in play?

A: Only the Gemini Engine gets the bonus. The token is named"Twin," not"Gemini Engine." The smart play is to play the Echoing Courage before attacking. That way, you'll get a larger Gemini Engine, and the Twin will have the great power and toughness.

Q: If I Imprint Recuperate onto Mourner's Shield, do I have to pay anything to use the spell, or have I just created a way to lavish 6 points onto myself every turn? Additionally, do you get to choose between the two abilities on the card or do you choose one at the imprint stage?

A: Imprinting a card gives you the opportunity to play that card only if the ability specifically says so. Mourner's Shield doesn't. It only looks at the color of the Imprinted card for the purpose of preventing damage of that card's color(s). If you had Imprinted Recuperate on something that allows you to play the spell, you could choose the mode when you announce the spell.

Q: I know mana abilities don't use the stack. So, if I want to mana burn on my opponent's turn (I'm playing with Mirror Universe), I can wait for him to pass priority on an empty stack at the end of his second main phase, float some mana and pass, and there's nothing he can do about it, right?

A: Wrong. Taking any game action or any game event occurring, even one that doesn't use the stack, breaks the"pass in succession" chain. After your mana ability resolves, you still have priority. If you pass and then he passes, the game will move to the next Phase.

Q: Suppose I have Mycosynth Lattice and Karn, Silver Golem in play. Can I use Karn's ability to turn noncreature artifacts into artifact creatures, as an extremely cheap way of destroying my opponent's lands by making them 0/0 creatures?

A: Yes. With the Lattice in play, the lands are noncreature artifacts. As soon as Karn animates them, they'll be 0/0 creatures because the converted mana cost of lands is 0. They'll be put into the graveyard as a State-Based Effect.

  •  
  •  
« Previous Article
Limited - How Powerful is Modular?
Next Article »
Yawgmoth’s Whimsy # 94: Playtesting and Inbreeding

About Sheldon Menery

Judge Emeritus Sheldon Menery is one of the most influential judges in the history of the game. He popularized Magic Q&A here on SCG with "Ask the Judge" and was a leading force in redefining fair play at the professional level. He pioneered Commander and is the public face of the format. He has Head Judged countless Pro Tours, World Championships, and Grand Prix and has played in five National Championships. He lives in Tampa, Florida with his wife Gretchyn and their five cats: Dasher, Cupid, Comet, Vito, and Vixen.

SheldonMenery

Read more by
Sheldon Menery



ORGANIZED PLAY
  • THIS WEEKEND
  • NEXT WEEKEND
  • +
  • THIS Saturday, May 25
  • OPEN Dallas/Fort Worth, TX
  • Super IQ Indian Trail, NC - Be There Games
  • Super IQ Orlando, FL - The Game Academy
  • IQ Duluth, MN - Berserkson!
  • IQ Tallahassee, FL - Gamescape
  • IQ Valley Stream, NY - Mark's Comics & Collectibles
  • IQ Tempe, AZ - Pop Culture Paradise
  • IQ Eau Claire, WI - Nomad Game Center
  • THIS Sunday, May 26
  • OPEN Dallas/Fort Worth, TX
  • Super IQ Tallahassee, FL - Gamescape
  • IQ Farmingdale, NY - Empire Gaming & Comics
  • Saturday, June 1
  • OPEN Baltimore, MD
  • Super IQ Denver, CO - Denver Comic Con!
  • IQ Columbus, OH - Comic Town
  • IQ Louisville, KY - Bluegrass Magic
  • IQ St. Louis, MO - Ogres Games
  • IQ Reno, NV - Comic Kingdom
  • IQ Houston, TX - R&R Comics
  • IQ Spokane Valley, WA - Trade Winds Gaming Zone
  • Sunday, June 2
  • OPEN Baltimore, MD
  • IQ Kansas City, MO - Spanky's Card Shop
  • IQ Staten Island, NY - Get There Games

STARCITYGAMES.COM EVENTS

  • May 25-26: OPEN Dallas/Fort Worth, TX
  • Jun 1-2: OPEN Baltimore, MD
  • Jun 8-9: OPEN St. Louis, MO
  • Jun 15-16: OPEN Columbus, OH at Origins Game Fair
  • Jun 22-23: OPEN Philadelphia, PA
  • Jun 28-30: GRAND PRIX Miami, FL
  • Jul 6-7: OPEN Worcester, MA
  • Jul 20-21: OPEN Richmond, VA
  • Jul 20: CLASSIC Lansing, MI
  • Jul 26-28: INVITATIONAL Somerset, NJ

ELITE QUALIFIERS

  • Jun 9: Atomic Empire - Durham, NC
  • THIS WEEK: See all Open Trials

EVENT FINDER

  • Complete SCG Schedule - Coverage Archive
NEWS
  • 5/24 August FNM Promo: Dimir Charm
  • 5/24 New Duels 2014 Decks!
  • 5/24 Vote SCG's Gerard Fabiano for KotN!
  • 5/23 Big M14 Rules Update!
  • 5/23 M14 and MTGMM Albums updated!
  • 5/22 YMTC 4 Final Round!
  • 5/21 Weekend Results! May 18-19
  • 5/16 M14 Spoiler: Megantic Sliver
  • 5/15 M14 Spoiler: Vastwood Hydra
  • 5/14 Weekend Results! May 11-12
  • 5/14 YMTC4 Voting Begins!
  • 5/10 The Final Greg Staples Lithograph is...
  • View All News Items - Submit Magic News
DECKLISTS
  • STANDARD
  • LEGACY
  • MODERN
  • 5/19 SCG Classic Springfield, US
  • 5/19 SCG Open Nashville, US
  • 5/19 Invi Qualifier Doylestown, US
  • 5/18 Invi Qualifier FAYETTEVILLE, US
  • 5/18 SCG Super IQ Littleton, US
  • 5/18 Invi Qualifier Roanoke, US
  • 5/18 Invi Qualifier Columbus, US
  • 5/18 Invi Qualifier Concord, US
  • 5/12 SCG Classic Pittsburgh, US
  • 5/12 Pro Tour Qualifier Chicago, US
  • 5/12 Pro Tour Qualifier Madison, US
  • 5/12 SCG Open Charlotte, US
View More Standard Decks - Search Decklists
  • 5/19 SCG Super IQ Milano, US
  • 5/12 Grand Prix Portland, US
  • 4/07 Invi Qualifier Glen Burnie, US
  • 3/17 Grand Prix San Diego, US
  • 3/17 Pro Tour Qualifier Melbourne, AU
  • 3/10 MTGO Daily Event
  • 3/10 Pro Tour Qualifier Magic Online,
  • 3/03 Pro Tour Qualifier Roanoke, US
  • 3/03 Pro Tour Qualifier Philadelphia, US
  • 3/03 Pro Tour Qualifier Toronto, CA
  • 3/03 Pro Tour Qualifier Madison, US
  • 3/03 Pro Tour Qualifier Magic Online,
View More Modern Decks - Search Decklists
  • 5/19 SCG Open Nashville,
  • 5/19 SCG Open Nashville, US
  • 5/19 Invi Qualifier Columbus, US
  • 5/12 Annecy, FR
  • 4/21 SCG Open Seattle, US
  • 4/14 Invi Qualifier Bristol, US
  • 4/14 SCG Open Milwaukee, US
  • 4/07 SCG Open Atlanta, US
  • 4/07 SCG Invitational Atlanta,
  • 4/07 SCG Invitational Atlanta, US
  • 3/24 SCG Open Kansas City, US
  • 3/17 SCG Open Washington, US
View More Legacy Decks - Search Decklists
SOCIAL

StarCityGames.com on Facebook


StarCityGames.com on Twitter

Join the conversation


WEEKLY NEWSLETTER

Exclusive Deals & Content Every Week



 

ACCOUNT
  • Login/Register
  • My Account
  • Order History
  • Credit History
  • Wishlists
  • Premium
  • Digital Items
  • Gift Card Redemption
CONTACT US
  • Customer Service/Order Issues
  • Advertising
  • Articles
  • Game Center
  • Gift Cards
  • Inventory Issues
  • Organized Play
  • SCG Premium
  • Selling to SCG
  • Shipping
  • Submit News
  • Website Bugs/Problems
ORDER QUESTIONS
  • Customer Service Hours
    Monday through Friday
    10AM - 6PM EST
    Ph: (540) 767-GAME (4263)
  • Email
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Refund/Return Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Statement
  • About StarCityGames.com
SCG ORGANIZED PLAY
  • Overview
  • Schedule
  • Coverage Archives
  • Invitational Qualifiers
  • Host an Invitational Qualifier
  • Judge Rewards
  • Open Points
  • Standings
  • SCGLive
GAME CENTER
  • Star City Game Center
    5728 Williamson Road N.W.
    Roanoke, VA 24012
    Ph: (540) 767-GAME(4263)
  • Email
  • Hours & Info
ARCHIVES
  • Search our Articles
  • Coverage Archives
  • RSS Feed
MORE SCG
  • SCGMobile
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Newsletter
  • SCGLive
  • TheManaDrain.com
  • CubeDrafting.com
All original content on this page is © 2012 StarCityGames.com and may not be used or reproduced without consent. Wizards of the Coast, Magic: The Gathering, and their logos are trademarks of Wizards of the Coast LLC. © 2012 Wizards. All rights reserved. StarCityGames.com is not affiliated with Wizards of the Coast LLC.