• STORE
  • EVENTS
  • ARTICLES
  • NEWS
  • DECKS
  • BUYLIST
  • HELP
Advanced Search
Deck Builder
  • Hello. Sign In.
    YOUR ACCOUNT

    forgot your password?

    New customer? Start here!

  • CART

    View Cart ( items)

    Checkout

  • WISH
    LIST
       
  • Magic Singles
    • English
    • Foil English
    • Non-English
    • Foil Non-English
    • BGS/Graded Cards
    • Complete Sets
    • Misprints and Rarities
    • Wholesale Lots
  • Magic Sealed Product
    • Expansion Sets
    • Booster Packs
    • Booster Boxes
    • Starter & Tourn. Packs
    • Starter & Tourn. Displays
    • Theme Decks
    • Event Decks
    • Intro Packs
    • Fat Packs
    • Two-Player Games
    • Standalone Sets
    • Archenemy
    • Commander
    • Duel Decks
    • From the Vault
    • Planechase
    • Premium Deck Series
    • Misc. Box Sets
    • Non-English Sealed
  • Gaming Supplies
    • Binders
    • Books & Fat Pack Guides
    • Boxes & Bags
    • Clothing
    • Deck Boxes
    • Dice
    • Life Counters
    • Playmats
    • Sleeves
  • Specialty Items
    • Ascension
    • Gift Cards
    • Lithographs
    • Original Artwork
  • Digital Products
    • Grinder: The Brad Nelson Story
    • Next Level Magic
    • OMG: Official Miser's Guide
    • Tha Gatherin'
  • We Buy

Ask the Judge, 03/23/2004

Sheldon Menery
3/23
  •  
  •  

Rules Tip of the Day: A mana ability is either (a) an activated ability that could put mana into a player's mana pool when it resolves or (b) a triggered ability that triggers from a mana ability and could produce additional mana. A mana ability can generate other effects at the same time it produces mana. Spells that put mana into a player's mana pool aren't mana abilities (rules 406.1 and 406.2).

Q: I have two Blinkmoth Nexus in play and a Skullclamp. During my turn, I activate one Nexus to make it a 1/1 artifact creature. I use the second Nexus to pump it up to a 2/2. I equip it with Skullclamp to make it a 3/1 and attack with it. What happens at the end of turn?

A: At End of Turn, nothing happens. During Cleanup, however, all"until end of turn" effects wear off. The Nexus simultaneously loses the +1/+1 and becomes just a land again, and then Skullclamp falls off. By the time State-Based Effects are checked, it's no longer a creature. It will stay in play.

Q: I play Bane of the Living and flip him for 2, killing five of my opponent's creatures. He wants to play Caller of the Claw after the Morph-triggered ability resolves, but I tell him that Bane's ability says all creatures in play get -2/-2 until end of the turn so this would kill any 2/2 that come into play later. He says I'm wrong. What do you say?

A: I say..."Ni!" Actually, I say that your friend is right. Continuous effects of abilities only apply to what was in play when they resolve (rule 418.3b). Caller of the Claw and the Bear tokens will survive just fine.

Q: My opponent has two creatures and I have a Ravenous Baloth in play. On my turn, I play Pulse of the Tangle. Is there an opportunity for me to sacrifice the beast token produced by Pulse of the Tangle to be able to get back Pulse of the Tangle to my hand?

A: No. You decide during resolution of Pulse of the Tangle if you can put it back in your hand or not. You don't get priority to activate the Baloth's ability during resolution.

Q: What can I use for tokens?

A: You can use anything you want for tokens except for the cards you're playing (meaning you can't use sideboard cards), so long as they're easily identifiable and not generally considered offensive. I recommend using something that's at least vaguely rectangular so everyone can tell whether or not it's tapped. Right here at Star City we have some great token cards. http://sales.starcitygames.com/customer/home.php?cat_1

Note that what might be considered inoffensive in, say, Europe, might be considered so in America. The Head Judge is the final arbiter.

Q: What happens if Opalescense is in play and Day of the Dragons comes into play? Is this a loop?

A: Yes, it's an unbound loop. Day of the Dragons comes into play as a 7/7 creature, then its comes-into-play triggered ability goes on the stack. When it resolves, all creatures are removed from the game, including Day of the Dragons. You get an equal amount of 5/5 Dragon tokens. Since Day of the Dragons left play, the leaves-play ability triggers, and you sacrifice the Dragons in play, bringing the removed cards, including Day of the Dragons back. The cycle starts again, so unless a player can to break the loop by winning the game, Stifling one of the triggered abilities, or destroying Opalescence or Day of the Dragons, the game will be a draw (rule 102.6).

Q: I have Phyrexian Plaguelord, Grave Pact, and Solemn Simulacrum in play. My opponent has an active untapped Goblin Sharpshooter in play. I sack the Solemn to the Plaguelord to give the Sharpshooter -1/-1. I am unclear as to how all of the effects resolve and how many times my opponent will get to use his Sharpshooter to shoot me in the eye before it dies.

A: It depends on whose turn it is. You announce activation of the Plaguelord. It goes on the stack. You sacrifice the Simulacrum to pay the cost. Grave Pact, the Simulacrum, and Goblin Sharpshooter all trigger. When multiple abilities trigger of the same event, you stack them in APNAP (active player, non-active player) order.

If it's your turn, you stack Gravepact and Simulacrum (in either order since you control both) first and then Sharpshooter. After all that goes on the stack, your opponent can tap the Sharpshooter to do one to you. Then, after the Sharpshooter's triggered ability resolves, he can activate it again before he has to sacrifice it to the Gravepact (for a total of 2 damage). You resolve the Simulacrum trigger, and then the Plaguelord's ability is countered on resolution due to an invalid target.

If it's your opponent's turn, the Sharpshooter trigger goes on the stack first and then your two. He can tap the Sharpshooter once to deal damage to you, but he'll have to sacrifice it to the Gravepact before he can untap it again.

Q: If I have out Ivory Mask can I still gain life from a card such as Noble Purpose or Words of Worship?

A: Yes, you can. Neither of those abilities is targeted. As is mentioned nearly daily in"Ask the Judge," you'll know a targeted ability by the use of the word"target."

Q: I imprint a Cunning Wish in my Panoptic Mirror. During my next upkeep, I activate the Mirror. Since the Wish tells me that I should"Remove ~this~ from the game" after playing the spell, what should I do? The card is already removed from the game. Should it stay there? The Mirror still works, right ?

A: You try to remove the copy of the Cunning Wish from the game, but you can't because there's no physical card. As soon as the copy leaves the stack, it ceases to exist (rule 420.5j). The original Cunning Wish stays Imprinted and the Mirror still works.

Q: Now suppose that for some reason I want the Cunning Wish back in my hand. I use the Mirror to copy the Imprinted card (the Wish) in order to look for a card in the RFG Zone (the SAME Wish) and put it in my hand. Can I do that? And if I can, would that make the Mirror useless after all (because now there is no card Imprinted)?

A: Yes, you can do that, and you'd have a useless Mirror until you Imprint something else on it.

Q: Will a Shriveling Rot played in life loss mode, trigger on a creature being sacrificed to a Sneak Attack at end of turn?

A: Yes. Shriveling Rot's effect lasts"until end of turn," which is during the Cleanup Step. Sneak Attack instructs you to sacrifice the creature"at end of turn," which happens during the End Step, which happens before Cleanup.

  •  
  •  
« Previous Article
Ask the Judge, 03/24/2004
Next Article »
De Rosa's Ramblings: Stop Complaining and Tighten Up!

About Sheldon Menery

Judge Emeritus Sheldon Menery is one of the most influential judges in the history of the game. He popularized Magic Q&A here on SCG with "Ask the Judge" and was a leading force in redefining fair play at the professional level. He pioneered Commander and is the public face of the format. He has Head Judged countless Pro Tours, World Championships, and Grand Prix and has played in five National Championships. He lives in Tampa, Florida with his wife Gretchyn and their five cats: Dasher, Cupid, Comet, Vito, and Vixen.

SheldonMenery

Read more by
Sheldon Menery



ORGANIZED PLAY
  • THIS WEEKEND
  • NEXT WEEKEND
  • +
  • THIS Saturday, May 18
  • OPEN Nashville, TN
  • CLASSIC Springfield, MA
  • Super IQ Myrtle Beach, SC - XCON Comics
  • Super IQ Glen Burnie, MD - Squabbles Trading Cards
  • Super IQ Littleton, CO - Black Gold
  • Super IQ Spokane Valley, WA - Trade Wind Gaming Zone
  • IQ Columbus, OH - Comic Town
  • IQ Phillipsburg, NJ - Aunt Lee's Nevermoor
  • IQ Concord, CA - Black Diamond Games
  • IQ Suwanee, GA - The Tower Game Center
  • IQ Fayetteville, NC - Cardz-N-Things
  • IQ Clarks Summit, PA - Full of Win Games
  • IQ Roanoke, VA - Star City Game Center
  • IQ Chatsworth, CA - All Ways Gaming
  • THIS Sunday, May 19
  • OPEN Nashville, TN
  • Super IQ Milano, Italy - Casa Dei Giochi
  • IQ Doylestown, PA - Cyborg One
  • IQ Kansas City, MO - Spanky's Card Shop
  • IQ East Stroudsburg, PA - The Gauntlet Cards & Games
  • IQ Marietta, GA - Raven's Nest Games
  • IQ Coos Bay, OR - His Junk / Her Treasures
  • Saturday, May 25
  • OPEN Dallas/Fort Worth, TX
  • Super IQ Indian Trail, NC - Be There Games
  • Super IQ Orlando, FL - The Game Academy
  • IQ Duluth, MN - Berserkson!
  • IQ Tallahassee, FL - Gamescape
  • IQ Valley Stream, NY - Mark's Comics & Collectibles
  • IQ Tempe, AZ - Pop Culture Paradise
  • IQ Eau Claire, WI - Nomad Game Center
  • Sunday, May 26
  • OPEN Dallas/Fort Worth, TX
  • Super IQ Tallahassee, FL - Gamescape
  • IQ Farmingdale, NY - Empire Gaming & Comics

STARCITYGAMES.COM EVENTS

  • May 18-19: OPEN Nashville, TN
  • May 18: CLASSIC Springfield, MA
  • May 25-26: OPEN Dallas/Fort Worth, TX
  • Jun 1-2: OPEN Baltimore, MD
  • Jun 8-9: OPEN St. Louis, MO
  • Jun 15-16: OPEN Columbus, OH at Origins Game Fair
  • Jun 22-23: OPEN Philadelphia, PA
  • Jun 28-30: GRAND PRIX Miami, FL
  • Jul 6-7: OPEN Worcester, MA
  • Jul 20-21: OPEN Richmond, VA

ELITE QUALIFIERS

  • Jun 9: Atomic Empire - Durham, NC
  • THIS WEEK: See all Open Trials

EVENT FINDER

  • Complete SCG Schedule - Coverage Archive
NEWS
  • 5/16 M14 Spoiler: Megantic Sliver
  • 5/15 M14 Spoiler: Vastwood Hydra
  • 5/14 Weekend Results! May 11-12
  • 5/14 YMTC4 Voting Begins!
  • 5/10 The Final Greg Staples Lithograph is...
  • 5/9 Revisions to Premier Play Changes
  • 5/9 Check out the #3 Greg Staples Lithograph...
  • 5/8 Greg Staples Lithograph #2 is...
  • 5/7 Greg Staples lithograph #1 is...
  • 5/7 Slivers in M14! Sealed in D14!
  • 5/6 Weekend Results and News! May 4-5
  • 5/3 SCG presents: ZOMBIES!
  • View All News Items - Submit Magic News
DECKLISTS
  • STANDARD
  • LEGACY
  • MODERN
  • 5/12 SCG Classic Pittsburgh, US
  • 5/12 Pro Tour Qualifier Chicago, US
  • 5/12 Pro Tour Qualifier Madison, US
  • 5/12 SCG Open Charlotte, US
  • 5/05 Invi Qualifier Lenexa, US
  • 5/05 Invi Qualifier Bristol, US
  • 5/05 SCG Elite IQ Centerville, US
  • 5/05 Invi Qualifier north myrtle beach, US
  • 5/05 SCG Open Somerset, US
  • 5/04 Invi Qualifier Tahlequah, US
  • 5/04 SCG Super IQ Wichita, US
  • 5/04 Invi Qualifier Charlotte, US
View More Standard Decks - Search Decklists
  • 5/12 Grand Prix Portland, US
  • 4/07 Invi Qualifier Glen Burnie, US
  • 3/17 Grand Prix San Diego, US
  • 3/17 Pro Tour Qualifier Melbourne, AU
  • 3/10 MTGO Daily Event
  • 3/10 Pro Tour Qualifier Magic Online,
  • 3/03 Pro Tour Qualifier Roanoke, US
  • 3/03 Pro Tour Qualifier Philadelphia, US
  • 3/03 Pro Tour Qualifier Toronto, CA
  • 3/03 Pro Tour Qualifier Madison, US
  • 3/03 Pro Tour Qualifier Magic Online,
  • 3/03 Pro Tour Qualifier West Nyack, US
View More Modern Decks - Search Decklists
  • 5/12 Annecy, FR
  • 4/21 SCG Open Seattle, US
  • 4/14 SCG Open Milwaukee, US
  • 4/14 Invi Qualifier Bristol, US
  • 4/07 SCG Invitational Atlanta, US
  • 4/07 SCG Open Atlanta, US
  • 4/07 SCG Invitational Atlanta,
  • 3/24 SCG Open Kansas City, US
  • 3/17 SCG Open Washington, US
  • 3/10 SCG Open Indianapolis, US
  • 3/03 SCG Open Las Vegas, US
  • 2/17 SCG Open Cincinnati, US
View More Legacy Decks - Search Decklists
SOCIAL

StarCityGames.com on Facebook


StarCityGames.com on Twitter

Join the conversation


WEEKLY NEWSLETTER

Exclusive Deals & Content Every Week



 

ACCOUNT
  • Login/Register
  • My Account
  • Order History
  • Credit History
  • Wishlists
  • Premium
  • Digital Items
  • Gift Card Redemption
CONTACT US
  • Customer Service/Order Issues
  • Advertising
  • Articles
  • Game Center
  • Gift Cards
  • Inventory Issues
  • Organized Play
  • SCG Premium
  • Selling to SCG
  • Shipping
  • Submit News
  • Website Bugs/Problems
ORDER QUESTIONS
  • Customer Service Hours
    Monday through Friday
    10AM - 6PM EST
    Ph: (540) 767-GAME (4263)
  • Email
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Refund/Return Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Statement
  • About StarCityGames.com
SCG ORGANIZED PLAY
  • Overview
  • Schedule
  • Coverage Archives
  • Invitational Qualifiers
  • Host an Invitational Qualifier
  • Judge Rewards
  • Open Points
  • Standings
  • SCGLive
GAME CENTER
  • Star City Game Center
    5728 Williamson Road N.W.
    Roanoke, VA 24012
    Ph: (540) 767-GAME(4263)
  • Email
  • Hours & Info
ARCHIVES
  • Search our Articles
  • Coverage Archives
  • RSS Feed
MORE SCG
  • SCGMobile
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Newsletter
  • SCGLive
  • TheManaDrain.com
  • CubeDrafting.com
All original content on this page is © 2012 StarCityGames.com and may not be used or reproduced without consent. Wizards of the Coast, Magic: The Gathering, and their logos are trademarks of Wizards of the Coast LLC. © 2012 Wizards. All rights reserved. StarCityGames.com is not affiliated with Wizards of the Coast LLC.