The Magic Show #123 – Grand Prix: Atlanta
Hello everybody, and welcome to another edition of the Magic Show. This week we're live in Atlanta, discussing Magic with the biggest and brightest in the game. Hear about the Magic Pro lifestyle, their thoughts on Extended Elves, the importance of luck, sizing up unknown opponents, a judge chat with Riki Hayashi, and more. Let's go!
Topics (in order):
Magic Pro Lifestyle (1:08 mark)
Size Up Players (3:17)
The Infamous Crown Royal Dice Bag (4:20)
Elves (5:14)
The Importance of Luck (7:35)
Judge Talk with Riki Hayashi (8:36)
Chess Clocks (9:19)
California States (10:40)
Letters from Toby (11:24)
Special Text-Only Section
For those who like to play along at home, I had a 1-round bye in Atlanta, and was confident I had a very good chance at Day 2 when I opened this monster of a pool:
…
…
…
…
…
…
C’mon, try and build it yourself.
…
…
…
…
…
Okay, here’s what I sleeved up:
Quick synopsis:
In Round 2 I played Robert. Game 1 I crushed him with Caldera Hellion, that sneaks up on everybody, and in game 2 Dragon Fodder tokens deals 6 damage before Spearbreaker Behemoth showed up to finish the game out.
Round 3 I got blown out by Flameblast Dragon in Game 1, as he is wont to do, in Game 2 my Elvish Visionary deals six damage before Caldera Hellion wraths the board and wins the game for me. Game 3 is decided by 1/1s, as I’m not dealt a point of damage while my Goblin Mountaineer, Rockslide Elemental, and Dragon Fodder tokens take it home.
Round 4 I play Chris and take him down Game 1 with Dragon Fodder tokens and Carrion Thrash. Note I didn’t mark when my opponent got manascrewed, which could’ve very well happened, obviously. Anyway, Game 2 Vein Drinker shows up to kick my ass and tag teams it Batman & Robin style with Algae Gharial backup. Yeah. Insane. I can’t find one of my two Bloodpyre Elementals to deal with her and the Vampire and Crocodile take it home. Game 3 my Wild Nacatl gets in there early along with an unblockable Goblin Mountaineer. Rhox Charger joins the party and soon he’s in single digits. Then it’s Spearbreaker Behemoth time, along with Hissing Iguanar to make blocking and not dying impossible.
Round 5 I play against Naoto, a.k.a. Billy. Billy is bringing the bombs. Game 1 I lose to Double Dragon (a.k.a. Broodmate Dragon). Game 2 I keep a slow hand while his Elvish Visionary takes 5 out of my ass. Soon another Elvish Visionary and then Wild Nacatl show up, and my slow draw can’t stop the beats or his removal for my blockers.
In Round 6 Rip-Clan Crasher deals 9 damage in Game 1 all while fighting monsters like Battlegrace Angel, with Carrion Thrash helping him mop up. Game 2 I didn’t get dealt a point of damage as Rockslide Elemental went all the way with a little help from Bloodpyre Elemental.
Round 7 I sat next to Guillaume Wafo-Tapa and got my ass handed to me by Brent. His Vein Drinker saw no removal for me and my Wild Nacatl wasn’t enough to kill him by any means. Game 2 he has an Algae Gharial that gets to ridiculous proportions and I can’t stop it. Now I’m X-2 and most likely not able to make Day 2 because of my low tiebreakers.
Round 8 I played a 3-game match versus Justin, where in Game 1 it was all about Rip-Clan Crasher dealing 6 damage and his buddy Drumhunter helping with the rest. Game 2 my Elvish Visionary tried to go all the way as an Exalted 2/2, but his Carrion Thrashes were too great. Game 3 I just crushed him but am not exactly sure how. Wild Nacatl got him to 15, Blightning to 12, and then his life total is listed as 1. Hrm.
Round 9 I played against former World Champ Carlos Romão. I would like to say I scooped him into Day 2, as there was probably no way I could make it and he had the 3-bye advantage. But of course I battled. Game 1 Wild Nacatl got him to 11, Rhox Charger took him to 6, and a Wild Nacatl dealt three more and Soul’s Fired him out of the game. Game 2 his Blister Beetle took out my Hissing Iguanar, quite the sweet play, and his double Blightning just obliterated my chances. Game 3, I’m positive, I punted quite badly. Almost every turn it felt like I was doing something wrong. I’m not exactly sure of which mistakes I was making, but it felt like I was making mistakes. I wish I could word that better, but regardless I lost and Carlos made Day 2.
Until next week Magic players, this is Evan Erwin. Tapping the cards...so you don’t have to.
Evan “misterorange” Erwin
eerwin +at+ thegmails +dot+ thecoms
dubyas dubyas dubyas dots misterorangeproductions dots coms








Friday, November 21st - Zac Hill makes a temporary move to Premium for this intensely detailed examination of his preparation for...
Friday, November 21st - Nick continues his Drafting With series, bringing us a triple Shards of Alara draft from the 8-4 queue on Magic Online. Along with Rich, he shares his pick process and draft thoughts with each one, and...
Monday, November 24th - I just looked through Magic’s first six expansions, hunting for old bargains – every card in Arabian...
Monday, November 24th - I have a rogue streak. I’m not surprising any of you with this statement (I hope). Truth is, I should probably netdeck more. A lot...
Monday, November 24th - On This week's Magic Sock podcast, there's a discussion of some of the top cards that have been banned over the years, a look back at the goodies from Torment, and much
Monday, November 24th - In a break from his usual Vintage exploration, Stephen Menendian explores a Mental Magic format that showcases analytical thought in its...
Thursday, November 20th - I just finished reading Patrick Chapin’s 100th article – his retrospective. I’m also at a numeric milestone, and I wanted to...
Thursday, November 20th - Back in 2003, I brought the New York Format out of obscurity and into my Compendium as a legitimate...
Thursday, November 20th - Canadian Draft maestro Rich Hoaen returns to the pages of StarCityGames.com. Each day, he brings us a triple Shards of Alara draft from Magic Online, from pick 1 to pick 45, sharing his insight on the...
Thursday, November 20th - The Reserve List is a list of 572(!) cards that Wizards of the Coast has promised to never reprint in tournament-legal form. But is...
Friday, November 21st - In today’s thought-provoking installment of Deep Analysis, Richard focuses on What Matters. He discusses the true role of logic, chaos theory, and the effect of miniscule changes on any given game, match,... 









