Levelling Up - U/B/R Control at Grand Prix: San Francisco
[SCROLL DOWN TO READ THE ARTICLE!]
Become a StarCityGames.com Premium Member and receive exclusive access to top-level strategies, new decklists and entertaining reports from many of the best players and writers that the game has to offer! This includes "The Innovator" & Worlds finalist Patrick Chapin, 2010 Player of the Year Brad Nelson, Classic Theorist Mike Flores, Hall of Famer Brian Kibler, GP and SCG Invitational Champion Gerry Thompson, StarCityGames.com Director of Sales Ben Bleiweiss ...and many, many more!
PLUS! StarCityGames.com Premium members now have an EXCLUSIVE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER sent just to them with the latest tech, exclusive content and exclusive deals along with unprecedented access into America's largest Magic: the Gathering sales database, and can view lists of StarCityGames.com's top-selling items - broken down by category, format legality, and rarity - in real time! When it comes to trading, increased knowledge equals increased profits - and increased knowledge is just one click away for our Premium members!
A StarCityGames.com Premium Membership gives you exclusive access to the best Magic: the Gathering content available and is an amazing bargain for just pennies a day! When you're ready to start getting more out of this game, click here to join StarCityGames.com Premium today!
If you are a valid StarCityGames.com Premium member and still cannot view the article, please consult this FAQ.
"Gatsby believed in the green light, the orgastic future that year by year recedes before us. It eluded us then,
but that's no matter - tomorrow we will run faster, stretch out our arms farther... And one fine morning..."
The Great Gatsby, F. Scott Fitzgerald
People ask me why I attend so many Grand Prix tournaments, spread all over the World. To the Far East to Kyoto, and to the Far West to San Francisco. I'm not looking for money, Pro Points, success, or acceptance.
But just like Jay Gatsby, I too have something that I wish, that I''ve dreamt of in the past. Something that I can only see as a green light at a distance, but something I will continue to focus on in order to reach it. I won't be repeating myself, but I just wanted everyone to know that my goals for this season weren't "material." They were to capture that green light that's off in the distance. And so I traveled to San Francisco.
Since everyone I know was uninterested in Block Constructed, either because they were playing Standard for Nationals or just sick of the Block format, I had no option but to test alone. I decided to continue the work I had done with U/B control. This is the last build I presented you here at StarCityGames.com:
| Blue/Black Control Featured by Tiago Chan on 2007-07-15 (Time Spiral Block) | ||
Artifacts 4 Prismatic Lens Artifact Creatures 1 Triskelavus Creatures 2 Aeon Chronicler 4 Shadowmage Infiltrator Enchantments 2 Take Possession |
Instants 4 Cancel 3 Careful Consideration 2 Mystical Teachings 1 Pull from Eternity 2 Slaughter Pact 3 Tendrils of Corruption Legendary Creatures 1 Teferi, Mage of Zhalfir Sorceries 4 Damnation Basic Lands 6 Island 1 Plains 1 Swamp Lands 1 Calciform Pools 4 Dreadship Reef 2 River of Tears 4 Terramorphic Expanse 1 Tolaria West 2 Urza's Factory Legendary Lands 1 Academy Ruins 4 Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth | 1 Aeon Chronicler 3 Aven Riftwatcher 3 Vesuvan Shapeshifter 1 Disenchant 1 Haunting Hymn 1 Snapback 1 Spell Burst 1 Strangling Soot 1 Tendrils of Corruption 1 Teferi, Mage of Zhalfir 1 Venser, Shaper Savant |
![]() |
![]() | |
| Download this deck in Apprentice format! |
Download this deck in Magic Online Text format! | |
I started playing eight-man queues on Magic Online, although they took around 40 minutes to fill during the Tenth Edition Release period. Gradually, I started making some changes.
I added Coalition Relic because it's such a poweful card.
I added spells that become stronger with the inclusion of Coalition Relic, such as Aeon Chronicler and Haunting Hymn.
I cut the Slaughter Pact to a single copy in the main, to be fetched with Tolaria West or Teachings, because there were fewer Griffin Guides and Red Akromas.
I added a Tolaria West and cut an Urborg. The extra Tolaria was to compensate for one fewer Urborg and one fewer Slaughter Pact, while the cutting of Urborg was because I went down to 26 lands with the Relics and couldn't risk having four Legendary Lands.
I added Void because it was awesome against Tarmogoyf based decks and good against almost every other deck. At some point, Void was the best card in the block.
With the addition of Red, I cut the White splash, removing Pull from Eternity and Aven Riftwatcher. They were mainly for the Mono Red matchup which was decreasing in popularity. Plus, I had played against the deck four times in Grand Prix tournaments and did no better than two losses and two draws.
These additional cards asked a price, which was paid by losing most of the deck's countermagic. I went from four Cancels down to one Cancel and one Venser, Shaper Savant. Venser is such a good card and tutor target, and I'm never unhappy of drawing it, and it was very important in some Take Possession / Urza's Factory battles. I still wanted to have one piece of pure countermagic because many times the deck achieves control but loses to a timely topdeck from the opponent. Usually that happens far past turn 7, so it shouldn’t be hard to hava mana open for Teachings and Cancel. Even if you do want to keep playing spells, just play Teachings for Cancel in one turn, so you only have to keep three open everytime.
I debated about running Pact of Negation instead of Cancel. The clear bonus is you can either play Teachings for the missing piece of Haunting Hymn / Pact of Negation to force the opponent to discard four cards in the mirror. I stuck with Cancel because it's a better card if you happen to draw it early on, and if people see one, or if you tutor for it, they'll assume you play many copies. But I'm not sure on the argument. I may be playing Pact of Negation the next time.
During mid August I spent a week visiting my parents in the South of Portugal. I decided to check the last PTQ in Portugal, held in the same region. As soon as I arrived, my good friend Frederico Bastos, which you may remember as my 2HG teammate at PT: San Diego, asked me if he should play Mono-Blue or Red/Green Mana Ramp. I answered it wouldn't matter, as he would do badly with either. His last individual Pro Tour was the first of 2003, and since then he never stopped playing or missed a PTQ season, so I guess if I werer a betting man he would be a tough guy to back.
But, always the nice guy, I challenged him to play with my latest version of U/B control, this time splashing Red for Void. I told him, if he was going to win a PTQ, it was with this baby. Since he wasn't very confident in either Mono Blue or R/G Mana Ramp, he accepted... and ten minutes before the start of the PTQ we went scrambling for the cards we here missing. (See the section "People who ask to borrow decks" from last week’s article.) This was cool because it allowed me to ask for those very same cards I’d need for GP: San Francisco.
Long story short, I spent the day playing with my deck against multiple matchups and opponents, and it proved to be extremely useful. I’ve already stressed how much I learn by playing paper Magic. Frederico also won the PTQ, which generated an enormous hype: the return of the King of Portuguese Magic. This gave me much confidence, and extra motivation to play the deck. For the rest of the time before the GP, I played a few eight-man Magic Online queues, although not many because they never filled. Here's what I ended up playing at San Francisco:
| U/B/R Control Featured by Tiago Chan on 2007-09-02 (Time Spiral Block) | ||
Artifacts 3 Coalition Relic 3 Prismatic Lens Artifact Creatures 1 Triskelavus Creatures 3 Aeon Chronicler 4 Shadowmage Infiltrator Enchantments 2 Take Possession |
Instants 1 Cancel 3 Careful Consideration 1 Haunting Hymn 2 Mystical Teachings 1 Slaughter Pact 3 Tendrils of Corruption Legendary Creatures 1 Venser, Shaper Savant Sorceries 4 Damnation 2 Void Basic Lands 6 Island 1 Mountain 2 Swamp Lands 3 Dreadship Reef 2 River of Tears 4 Terramorphic Expanse 2 Tolaria West 2 Urza's Factory Legendary Lands 1 Academy Ruins 3 Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth | 3 Detritivore 3 Vesuvan Shapeshifter 1 Ancient Grudge 1 Haunting Hymn 1 Imp's Mischief 3 Spell Burst 1 Strangling Soot 2 Void |
![]() |
![]() | |
| Download this deck in Apprentice format! |
Download this deck in Magic Online Text format! | |
I don't think this is the optimal list, but it was the one I arrived at while testing alone and playing some ocasional queues online. The good thing is that it has many similarities to the version Luis Scott-Vargas, Paul Cheon, and Paulo Vitor da Rosa designed. I feel happy to have reached it by myself, to draw some of the same conclusions as them. The bad thing is that it has some differences. Since they tested for longer, with more people, and achieved better results than I did, I'm going to assume they have a better version.
The Grand Prix started very well for me, as I went all the way to 6-0, but it wouldn't last. The rise started with a Round 4 match against Willy Edel. What's with the tough first round pairings? I always seem to play against players that I know in the first rounds of Grand Prix tournaments, so I tracked down some evidence to support this:
GP: Stockholm - Round 4 Arnost Zidek, Round 5 André Coimbra
GP: Strasbourg - Round 4 Julien Nuijten, Round 5 Shoota Yasooka
GP: Montreal - Round 4 Antoine Ruel
GP: San Francisco - Round 4 Willy Edel
The amazing thing is that these matches are all crossed in the win box, so clearly I'm not losing Grand Prix tourneys because of playing better/Well-known players, as I’ve proved I can hold my own against them. What happens most of the time is that in some key rounds everything goes as wrong as it possibly coud, and I can do nothing except brace for the loss, As if I’m involved in some sort of Grand Prix tragedy.
But enough ranting, as I got lucky in my first three rounds (four to six). Thanks to the inclusion of Void, the matchup against Tarmagoyf became better, and that's what I was paired against in my first rounds.
I won the match against Willy despite being on the draw both games, and despite missing my third land drop in one of them, because Willy had to mulligan three times and started with weak draws. In the one he mulliganed to five I had a sketchy Haunting Hymn hand, but since he wasn't playing much, the Hymn hit him for exactly his four remaining cards.
In the next round I was paired against a U/G Aggro-Goyf deck splashing Black for Shadowmage Infiltrator. It's a tougher matchup, but still favorable. I won the first quite easily, but was totally dominated in the second where he started with Looter and Shadowmage. I tried for Damnation on turn 4, but he Delayed it. Tendrils of Corruption on turn 5 met the same fate. His board was growing huge and I really needed my suspended Damnation to resolve on turn 7. By then my life was really low, but I managed to get the Cancel in my hand either by drawing it or fetching him with Careful Consideration or Teachings, so I was ready to fight for the Damnation. The Damnation was put in the stack and he played Venser on it, which he later admited being a mistake, as I let it resolve and just replayed Damnation, clearing the whole board plus Venser.
My final win that took me to 6-0 was against another G/W/R Goyf/Predator/Justice deck, and my opponent also didn't have an explosive draw. I didn’t need to play Void in the first game, and he was wrecked by it in the second, where a Void for four killed a Calciderm on the table plus two Mystic Enforcers in his hand.
After Round 6 there was a much-needed Lunch Break (at 6pm). Players used this free time to refresh themselves, while judges had to work through some problems. People usually point out to judges when things don't go perfect, but I respect them because they work at these events under a great deal of pressure, sometimes more than pro players. While a player can allow himself to have a bad day, everyone expects judges to have a flawless tournament. and as a consequence they wake up much earlier, go to sleep much later, and work non-stop all day. A big thank you to all Judges who help sustain Magic tournaments!
From here, all I needed was one more win for Day Two, the sooner (and the more) the better. Unfortunately I was paired against a bad matchup, one I had never won at a Grand Prix: Mono Red. I even almost gave up on testing it because it was decreasing in popularity, and I couldn't win even with a lot of sideboard space, so I had exactly one card to bring in: Strangling Soot.
I even got a 1-0 lead by playing Damnation on three creatures. He followed with Stormbind and went all in with that plan. I followed Damnation with Aeon Chonicler and finaly played Take Possession on the Stormbind, which I used the following turn to kill him. Games 2 and 3 were really close. I had a fair loss in game 2, but in game 3 I could've won had I played differently near the end. Both possible plays are long and complex to describe, because they involve reflecting about the game state, cards in play, life totals, and planning one or two turns ahead, but without perfect information I couldn't figure out which one was the best. After thinking about it for a while, I went with the one that I thought was safer, since it allowed me to play Tendrils of Corruption for life gain. After discovering what he was holding at the time, I now know I would've won if I had followed the other avenue of attack, so I had to blame myself for not examining the situation fully, or I can blame my intuition for failing to hit in a 50/50 shot.
At 6-1 I still had some room to breathe. I was paired against a U/G aggressive deck with Looter il-Kor and Goyf, but with so much countermagic. Delay, Venser, and Mystic Snake were present, to name a few, and he splashed for Momentary Blink to give they counter-guys an extra spin. We split the first two thanks to alternate weak draws from each of us. In game 3 there's nothing on the table, but there's a suspended Riftwing Cloudskate with two counters. He has mana open, so I assume he has Mystic Snake. I played Mystical Teachings at the end of his turn, assuming that if he has Mystic Snake it will also be bad for me when the Cloudskate comes into play. He countered it with the Snake, and had more of the same to protect the beatdown. Maybe I should've stayed quiet. I'm not sure it would help me win... it's just another possibility.
At 6-2 I'm forced to play an elimination match for Day two. My opponent starts. Interestingly, I went 0-6 in die rolls at this Grand Prix, which has happened a couple of times before at other Grand Prix tourneys, and also twice at Worlds (which used to be six rounds each day). It's still a far cry from my greatest streak of 0-14 in die rolls, which happened on Magic Online, but hey, this one's still alive going into Grand Prix: Firenze. I'm be very happy to break the 0-14 streak there, especially because that would mean I am playing on Day 2.
The first land he plays is Terramorphic Expanse which he cracked before his second turn to fetch an Island. His second play is Grove of the Burnwillows.
Stop.
The next two seconds slowed right down.
"Oh God, Terramorphic Expanse for Island and Grove of the Burnwillows... I know what he's playing, I know! I even wrote an article on this matchup! Man, it was so bad when I tested it! I hope it isn't what I'm thinking..."
Down came Gemhide Sliver. Followed by turn 3 Dormant, and turn 4 Firewake plus Frenetic Slivers. On my turn 4, I played Damnation. Unlike the die rolls, this time the statistics worked right. Two of them died, and two lived. Gemhide and Firewake went to graveyard, while Dormant and Frenetic returned at the end of turn and drew him two more cards. He kept playing more Slivers and drawing cards from them. I played an early Take Possession, thanks to Coalition Relic, on the Dormant to try to stay alive... on the very same turn he cycled for Psionic Sliver, played it, and used a Sliver to kill my Dormant, and attacked me for something like thirty damage and fifteen poison counters.
For game 2 I had a better hand, with card drawing, Cancel, and Spell Burst going first, so I could counter the key Frenetic and Dormant Slivers. He started with turn 1 Virulent and turn 2 Two-Headed. I don't have removal for either, so I cast turn 3 Shadowmage to dig one card further if I need to. He played turn 3 a second Virulent Sliver and attacked, putting me at five poison counters and able to deal me six next turn. His untapped lands are Mountain and Terramorphic Expanse. What to do in my turn?
I was holding lands, a second Shadowmage, Cancel, Spell Burst. I am dead next turn, if I don't nullify one of his attackers. I think I have two plays, both very risky.
1- Try to be really lucky: attack with Shadowmage, hoping to draw into a Damnation to clear his three Slivers, or at least a removal spell for one of the Virulents.
2- Play a second Shadowmage and don't attack. This way I can block one of them, receiving only four poison counters staying at nine. If this happened and he attacks, he would lose the Two-Headed Sliver, so the board would be two Virulents, which can't go through two Shadowmages anymore, so he has to play something else. If I'm again in the risk of losing the turn after, I can attack with both Shadowmages for two extra cards, plus the card of the turn... that's three fresh cards.
Play number 2 seemed a little better, or at least safer. I played the Shadowmage and passed. He cracked the Expanse to get an Island, played a second one on his turn, and played Telekinetic Sliver. He passed, and on my upkeep he tapped three of my four lands. I took mana, hoping to draw into a removal spell, but the game was lost. Even if I killed the one of the Virulents to stay alive, chances were I would stay locked long enough for him to win. He would have to deal six more poison counters, one at a time, but the chances of him not having more slivers, or for me to draw more instant removal, were slim I drew Damnation, and lost.
The funny thing is, the Damnation was indeed at the top of my deck. If I went boldly and risky for play number one, I could've won, or at least lived much longer. Sometimes the cards, be it our own or our opponent's, are indeed at the top of our decks when we need them. But that's not enough. We have to play for them and position ourselves for them to be useful when we draw them. That Damnation one draw step after was useless, while it would've been demolishing the turn before.
Some people claimed the Poison Slivers matchup was really good, like 90%-10% favouring Blue/Black. I still don't believe that. It seems a beating every time Blue/Black has the right answers for the different threats Slivers play, but if you have the wrong ones at the wrong, which is quite likely since they have four or five different angles of attack, then lose.
In retrospect, I regret not making the other call against Mono Red, and not making play number 1 against Slivers. I don't regret going to San Francisco despite scoring nothing. In San Jose I ate the best food ever on American soil. Side drafting was great, as usual. Cube drafting was a fun and new experience. Every Magic player I met, for the first time or as an old friend, provided great times. I've heard some American players are coming to Grand Prix: Firenze next week. I'll be really happy to see you all here for a Grand Prix in Europe, and I’ll do my best to return the hospitality... you'll be most welcomed.
See you all in Firenze,
Tiago









Hello everybody, and welcome to another edition of the Magic Show. This week we’re going to take a look at the first new card type since the introduction...
[Editor's Note: This article was a little late on Friday, so we're running it again today in case you missed it.]
When the word on Masters Edition finally broke out, I couldn't believe it. An Online only expansion? Whoa. Masters Edition is an attempt by Wizards to give...
Time Spiral Block Constructed season is winding to a close, and it’s time to move to Constructed pastures new. Traditionally, Block Constructed is the...
In today's only Charles Dickens reference here on StarCityGames.com, it's time to go all Scrooge-like with Rich Hagon, as he starts to explore ways to get the...
Right now, the Vintage metagame is an odd anomaly when you look at it from a competitive point of view. On one hand, the best players are winning and making Top...
He’s been supplying excellent Feature Articles week in and week out for quite some time now... and today, he debuts his weekly column (in place of the study-bound Prof). Adrian Sullivan is one of the finest deckbuilders and...
Now the Tenth Edition Release Events have finished, it’s business as usual with the Standard and Block Constructed Premier Events. Benjamin Peebles-Mundy...
With Time Spiral Block Constructed season winding down, and everyone holding their breath for news of Lorwyn trickling out from Wizards, Scrye, and other...
While I am often referred to as “Dr. Romeo“ in this column, I‘m not a doctor in the conventional sense of the word. I’m a doctor of jurisprudence. In other words, I just have the title of doctor, like Dr....
The sun is setting on Block Constructed season. The last tournament in my area was last weekend (I finished an unceremonious 2-1-2, after picking up a pair of...
This week’s Deep Analysis sees Richard bring a fresh perspective on metagaming to the table. If you look at your average Constructed PTQ or GP Top 8, you’ll see a number of different decklists doing well at the hands...
Now that we know that Lorwyn has a tribal theme, it seems like a solid idea to actually explore some tribal ideas and make some decks in homage to the new set....
Sportsmanship is a gray area in Magic. That's because everyone has a different idea about what sporting play is. Take, for instance, use of headphones while you are playing. To me it's a sign of disrespect, but others won't think...
Without a doubt, Tarmogoyf is the best creature in Legacy. Unsatisfied with current Threshold decks, Kevin presents several ideas on how to best use the Goyf. He... 










